chuckebaby


sure,sounds good then,i stand corrected and i apologize.

so,no one would mind if do the same either?
i had no idea,thats great because i do have 3 songs ready to be released and it may be a good idea to start a thread about how i feel about sonar as well and have those 3 songs at the top of my thread right under my name,with no disscusion. 

theres not even a discussion in the first post just simply a title and "o ya by the way,check out my new song. are you serious john?

your way off on this one john sorry,

ya it would be nice if it was in his sig like everyone else,do you not think so?

not even a discussion john,just a title man...
and o ya,my new song.
 
im sorry john,but think you see the words"sonar is awesome" and you completley go blind to any rules or tos or anything.
you know how i feel about sonar,this isnt about sonar,its about if everyone of us created a thread with no words except a title and our name,linking our new songs.
 
the x1/x2 forum would turn into the song forum.

Charlie I don't think you know me at all. I can see an objection when someone is doing something that is disruptive. I'm not pleased when some one is trying to sell me something and using this forum to do it. I see no harm what so ever in some one trying to be informative. In my view the tile on this thread is more than enough explanation. The link is saving a lot of words.

Why you infer that I can be blinded by a word is rather a little insulting. The nature of my post above did no such thing in that there was no insult. All I did was show a little inconsistency in what you ask others to do and what you are doing. What I didn't do was ask you or anyone to remove anything.   

One neat thing about links is no one is forced to click on them. 

I hope you are doing well and are not in any difficulty with the snow. 

Bub


Craig Anderton did it the other day, where was the outrage then?

Craig had special permission from the people at Cakewalk and there was a reason behind it. Although I don't remember the reason. I got to agree with Charlie on this. I think he has the right take on it. I also believe it is OK to put links to your music or your website in the signature. 


I should also say that I have heard some of Shawn's music. I liked it.


If people start posting songs in the x2 forum then it will become cluttered with threads to sift through and it will take away from the focus of X2. I suspect that is the reason for the song forum in the first place.


I do think on occasion when a song is posted it should be displayed with some sort of recording tip, like when Beepster posted his songs about TH2 producer tones. Those songs were recorded for the express purpose of displaying what the capabilities were in TH2 and not to promote Beepster's personal songs that he records and writes. There is a difference.


How many people called for God Particle to Display his work in this X2 area?. I think these are exceptions to the rule and serve to highlight X2 not the individual. That is where you draw the line.

John

chuckebaby


sure,sounds good then,i stand corrected and i apologize.

so,no one would mind if do the same either?
i had no idea,thats great because i do have 3 songs ready to be released and it may be a good idea to start a thread about how i feel about sonar as well and have those 3 songs at the top of my thread right under my name,with no disscusion. 

theres not even a discussion in the first post just simply a title and "o ya by the way,check out my new song. are you serious john?

your way off on this one john sorry,

ya it would be nice if it was in his sig like everyone else,do you not think so?

not even a discussion john,just a title man...
and o ya,my new song.

im sorry john,but think you see the words"sonar is awesome" and you completley go blind to any rules or tos or anything.
you know how i feel about sonar,this isnt about sonar,its about if everyone of us created a thread with no words except a title and our name,linking our new songs.

the x1/x2 forum would turn into the song forum.

Charlie I don't think you know me at all. I can see an objection when someone is doing something that is disruptive. I'm not pleased when some one is trying to sell me something and using this forum to do it. I see no harm what so ever in some one trying to be informative. In my view the tile on this thread is more than enough explanation. The link is saving a lot of words.

Why you infer that I can be blinded by a word is rather a little insulting. The nature of my post above did no such thing in that there was no insult. All I did was show a little inconsistency in what you ask others to do and what you are doing. What I didn't do was ask you or anyone to remove anything.   

One neat thing about links is no one is forced to click on them. 

I hope you are doing well and are not in any difficulty with the snow. 

thank you,
i wish you well john,sorry if i freaked out a little on you.
 
you might have read the post after he removed the link and thats why id didnt make sence.
im probably being over sensitive.but this isnt the first time.
 
if i remember correctly he also posted a colaboration between him and danny danzi in the sonar x1/x2 forum as well.
i think its unfair to other users who see less traffic in the song forum thats all.
 
my apologys for the "blind comment" that wa unfair as well.

Nice post OP! Always a drama post comes sneaking in when someone starts talking positive...

Marcus Curtis

Bub

Craig Anderton did it the other day, where was the outrage then?

Craig had special permission from the people at Cakewalk and there was a reason behind it.

The reason behind his post was the fact I made a comment in another thread to something of the effect that some of the people who claim to be professionals here have never posted a song. That's where it stemmed from.

It's not a big deal, I'm just pointing out that Shawn came on, stated how much he liked Sonar, gave an example of what you can do with it, and that's exactly what Craig did in his post.

Seems there's a dual standard here determined by status.

Shawn's a really nice guy and does incredible work with Sonar, in a genre that most of us old timers aren't too keen on. I think he's a prime example of just how versatile Sonar can be.

Anyway, not a big deal.

Thanks

Bub

Marcus Curtis

Bub

Craig Anderton did it the other day, where was the outrage then?

Craig had special permission from the people at Cakewalk and there was a reason behind it.

The reason behind his post was the fact I made a comment in another thread to something of the effect that some of the people who claim to be professionals here have never posted a song. That's where it stemmed from.

It's not a big deal, I'm just pointing out that Shawn came on, stated how much he liked Sonar, gave an example of what you can do with it, and that's exactly what Craig did in his post.

Seems there's a dual standard here determined by status.

Shawn's a really nice guy and does incredible work with Sonar, in a genre that most of us old timers aren't too keen on. I think he's a prime example of just how versatile Sonar can be.

Anyway, not a big deal.

Thanks

Budb

I don't dispute anything you just said, especially when it comes to Shawn and his music. Like I said, I have heard his stuff before. I don't think it is a major crime, but I do think it is something to take note of for future reference.


When I clicked on the topic it did appear to me to be more of an ad for his music then to express how great sonar is. This was my first impression.


Shawn did remove the link. I would say to Shawn, put the link in your signature and I will give it a listen! Your music has always been pretty good and I am sure I won't be disappointed. 


double standard? that may be, but I would seek permission before putting something in this area. I think Shawn had good intentions. I think he is a good guy. So yes no big deal.

Not to worry Charlie. Nothing has changed between us. I just hope those back East are OK.

FWIW, If the OP wants to convey that he thinks Sonar is a great tool... and offers an example of what can (and has been) accomplished with it... I don't really see that as a negative thing.
To be more politically correct, maybe a link to the tune posted in the Songs forum???   

so another cake cop blows up another positive topic with
a stupid comment about traffic on the forum
so as you asked for a little forgiving i say\no
its just a forum and a ADMIN would move it if needed.
 Right
so its just a case of (my music isnt here so your cant be).
who cares i say.if he tryed to get a few hits by trying to praise sonar and it dint hurt anyones feelings.
 but yours.
 i was going to listen to his happy tune but thanks to you i have no clue where it is.
this is a forum for cakewalk. if you recorded on sonar it should be welcome anywhere on there forum
 period..
 

This forum is getting as old as the software to make it run. I cant believe someone with a good heart gives a positive statement on the forum and then the other loosers who critisize everything that comes into the forum. What a bunch of crap.  Cake, please update the forum software and add new people to the forum.  The ones here have been here tooooooooooo long.
Danny