• Songs
  • "Let's have a "rework a classic" competition" _ emerald soul
2015/02/09 00:24:59
optimus
"Let's have a "rework a classic" competition"_ emeraldsoul
 
Ok this is by no means meant to be competitive. Just in the spirit of reworking classics.
To start things off, this is a song I recorded with the band some time back.
 
https://soundcloud.com/tags/li'l%20sister 
2015/02/09 08:03:45
Walt Collins
I don't know what you're referring to regarding a competition, but I listened to your song "Little Sister" and it was great!  Well done vocals and guitars, clean mix, solid!  I'm now following you on Soundcloud.
2015/02/09 08:32:46
garybrun
Very nice.Sounds great on my SE Eggs and JBL4412's.
2015/02/09 09:47:43
optimus
Sorry, I don't mean to be cryptic, but my posting is in response to Emeraldsoul's comment in responding to the posting of Witchita Linesman by markno999.
 
 "I love that I can hear reworkings of seminal songs here! Pretty unexpected, and very cool.
 
I think anyone would be hard pressed to recreate a classic like this with such accuracy (apart from some nice vocal noodling at the end) - it's just like putting a nickel in the jukebox. And I mean a nickel, NOT a quarter!
 
However, the one thing I don't think was in the original - seems like an added alien cricket synth patch, pitched way up high, panning left and right - supposed to add shimmer, which it does, but I would vote to cut its volume in half. Things like that are subliminal ear candy at best and should not be the center of attention in such a fine song as this. Just a thought . . .
 
Holy crap, great job. Let's have a "rework a classic" competition - you would win.
 
-Tom"
 
Waltenstein: Thanks for listening and the vote of confidence.
 
Garybrun: Thank you too
2015/02/09 11:20:50
Wookiee
Sounds like a well recorded and presented mix here, thanks for sharing.
2015/02/09 11:24:57
emeraldsoul
Hey now, is my throwaway comment now an idea?  :)
 
It would be fun to have a "kind of" competition, redoing a classic, but we'd have to agree on an era, a time frame for completion, and would probably have to define "classic." And most of us would prefer to work on our originals anyway?
 
On all counts, extremely difficult to pull off, I'm thinking. Probably better off just to offer up the old chestnuts as they come along.
 
Little Sister is pretty smooth, very well mixed, vocals nice and up front, TOTALLY dug the harmonica, needed more piano or a piano solo? Just a thought (from a piano player!)
 
At one point you have guitar solo and harmonica solo going on simultaneously, you might pan them harder r-L for clarity?
 
cool ending!
 
punchy bass is perfect for driving this tune ...
 
-Tom
2015/02/09 11:47:49
batsbrew
here's my submission:
 
"INTERSTATE SUN"
 

 
https://soundcloud.com/bats-brew/interstate-sun-2
2015/02/09 13:04:55
bapu
2015/02/09 19:06:53
optimus
emeraldsoul
Hey now, is my throwaway comment now an idea?  :)
 
It would be fun to have a "kind of" competition, redoing a classic, but we'd have to agree on an era, a time frame for completion, and would probably have to define "classic." And most of us would prefer to work on our originals anyway?
 
On all counts, extremely difficult to pull off, I'm thinking. Probably better off just to offer up the old chestnuts as they come along.
 
Little Sister is pretty smooth, very well mixed, vocals nice and up front, TOTALLY dug the harmonica, needed more piano or a piano solo? Just a thought (from a piano player!)
 
At one point you have guitar solo and harmonica solo going on simultaneously, you might pan them harder r-L for clarity?
 
cool ending!
 
punchy bass is perfect for driving this tune ...
 
-Tom


I don't really mean any sort of competition Tom, just thought it would be nice to hear other peoples take on old, as you put it, "chestnuts". I'm sure others have the odd cover sitting somewhere in a dusty folder.
 
Batsbrew: That rocks.
 
Bapu: Wasn't that Dylan's "sellout" song. Haven't heard it in years. I like it.
2015/02/14 23:01:55
evadianepug
OK, the Pugtones will play.  Here ya go.
 
Choo Choo Mama (Mark, Scotty and Warren)
https://app.box.com/s/48ralyxrpuzlzaqf220z0s9atj2elgfm
 
BTW, Little Sister was very nicely done.  I really enjoyed it.  And some of the others on this thread.  Rob tore up DP!.
 
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account