I'm playing around with converting a vocal track to MIDI using V-Vocal.

Overall it works fairly well, but some non-scale notes show up in the generated MIDI.

Within V-Vocal itself, after applying pitch correction, all sung notes are scale notes (in this case A major).

When I click the convert to MIDI button and drag it to my MIDI track, there are several Bb notes which shouldn't be there.

Since I've constrained the pitch correction to the A major scale and the pitch correction is good with no Bb's, how do they end up in the MIDI output ?

You might want to try getting those "bad notes" right on the scale note (A in this case) and then try the convert. That should work for you if you manually correct the offending notes. Robin

Thanks Robin, but that doesn't seem to work as it looks like V-vocal is generating the MIDI from the uncorrected clip, even after correcting.

What I've tried with better success is to bounce the corrected V-vocal clip so that all notes are ok, then convert that to MIDI.