For drums, I tried the Abbey Road 60s kits (with Komplete). The early 60s kit doesn't seem to have a heavy enough kick drum. The late 60s kit has a nicer kick.
However, the kit as a whole seems to have too much reverb or something; it sounds too much like a real drum set rather than a drum set on a record or CD. I know that sounds like a strange complaint (similar to people's complaint about 48 fps in the Hobbit movie), but the "realism" of the Abbey Road late 60s kit makes it sound different from traditional reggae.
I tried compression, but it didn't make it sound closer to the record.
So then I tried sending the kit through Guitar Rig (Komplete's amp simulator). I went through dozens of effect templates, mostly at random, but didn't find anything that sounded right.
So I'm a bit at a loss...
Is the Abbey Road 60s kit not a good starting place? I tried Studio Drummer (another Komplete kit), but that didn't sound right either.
Any tips on how to at least get the drums sounding consistent with that 70s Marley sound?