This feature has always been a big mess just waiting to happen. Ripple editing is supposed to be what you use know but I've yet to figure it out ( lazy) But what I do,,just did this last night to add an extra verse,
Make a SPLIT across all tracks in the places that make the beginning and end of the part your copying. Use Ctl A to select all tracks and make the SPLIT making sure it is at a measure ex: 3:01:00
If the part you are copying is 12 measures
Drag the right hand part of the song that will come after the paste to the right 14 bars out of harms way.
Now copy past int the blank space the 12 measures you want
Now drag the rest of the song back to where it belongs
Super clunky but that's my work around and it never fails.. Because I've gotten good at it I have not tried riple editing.