Hello Everyone,
 
New to this forum, wished I had gotten here sooner! I did a search and didn't have any luck with this question, hoping ya'll can give me some insight!
 
First a little about myself. I've been using mc5 on an old pc that bit the dust and now can't find my software to re-install the program. I mostly just use the program for my own entertainment, recording guitar and bass on recordings of old cover songs. Usually to consistency of mud.
 
Anyway, I'm torn between using MC6 or moving up to Studio X-2 but I'm not knowledgeable enough about recording to know if moving up would benefit me enough to justify the move.
 
Just looking for a comparison I guess.
 
Thanks for any input you might have to offer
 
 

First, list the specs of the system you use for your DAW. That will help us sort it out IMMENSELY.
Also include what type of sound card you use, etc.

The pc is a hp with amd e2-1800 apu with radeon hd graphics card
6 gig of ram using windows8 64 bit...kinda basic.
 
downloaded a trial version of studio x-2 producer and was able to get it working on a couple of tracks

a few things will happen, you will find that there are so many things you may very well be a little overwhelmed.
but if you go with a lighter version or ms6 you may find you don't have the tools to do the things you want.

here's the thing with sonar x2,
it has so many features that it actually brings out more creativity in you. you have more tools to do more things, thus expand your creative process.

this is most obvious in session drummer 3 compared to studio instruments.
or z3ta compared to cakewalk sound center.

I know a lot of people who have bought sonar essentials that had wished they bought producer.
there are more advanced features,but they're hidden so its not like its more confusing.

my advise is to take your time, try the demo, enjoy it.
if you find it is everything you love,then wait for a deal to pop up.
there are always deals on sonar x2 poping up here or there, like getting freebee's with your purchase or 100.- off the retail price.

welcome to the forum.

I would look strongly at Sonar X2 Producer. If X2 studio is working for you the value that Producer offers and the unique quality that it offers will serve you well. Pro Channel is a major benefit of the Producer version that should not be underestimated. Take a long look at it and see if it isn't a better choice. Further, this forum can be very supportive in helping you getting the most out of it. 

Last be not least. Welcome to the forum Jayberd.

   

thanks everyone for the welcome and the input....it seems producer is hands down around here. I always thought it was a little pricey for my skill set, want to buy but wasn't sure if I could learn enough about recording and mastering to use producer to its maximum potential.

Also, I know this PC isn't "studio" quality and I had enough trouble with MC5 crashing on the old pc.

Thanks everyone for the input, but I just found my copy of MC5 stuck in my file cabinet under "manuals" (found the manual there too :)). Gonna load it up and see what happens. Glad I found this forum tho, I'm sure I'll be a regular visitor.

Its not pricey when you consider what you get. As for learning you will learn no matter which DAW you use. Its part of the process so you might as well learn on the flagship version. 

Stick with MC5 or look into Presonus Studio One.
X2 (for me anyway) is still unstable.
You'll do more trouble shooting with X2 than recording.

That's just my 2 cents.

Mike

You'll do more trouble shooting with X2 than recording.

 
-1.    I don't do any troubleshooting with X2a.   Really, it does just work... a few quirks with Take Lanes aside.  
 
That said, based on the OP's current situation I'd suggest he stick with MC5 until he realizes that it doesn't offer everything he wants or needs, then look into upgrading.   IOW, upgrade based on want or need, not just for its own sake.