Janet asked me for a copy of the .wav, but it was lost in a system crash? So I went back in to the project and it was pretty old, I've learned a few things since then, so I remixed it. Janet played the piano and I did everything else, it's not bad.
 
https://soundcloud.com/rockinrobby/without-you-12-2014
 
We hope you like it.
 
H-
 
====
 
P.S., any mix comments are always welcome. Always trying to improve. I hope you have a blessed holiday season. 

I'm keenly interested in observations/comments on the ass end? (the bottom) I.e, is it big and round enough? Can you hear the bass well? Should there be more? But I am open to and thankful for any and all mix comments.
 
My humble headphone mix.
 
H-

Well played, well sung. The piano is huge..... perhaps just a bit too huge. I'm sure if you  tamed the piano a bit the other elements would come out more balanced. Otherwise nice.

That's what I needed man, thanks! I had the piano pushed a bit because she plays it, and it all started from there? I agree it needs to come back a bit. 
 
It's honest and good feedback like this that we should see more of? I'm pulling it back a bit now, and will re-post a new mix in a few. Thanks again for the ears.
 
H-

Yeah man, I pulled her back quite a bit? She's still out there, because the song needs the piano out there (IMO) But you made a good call, and she's been reeled in somewhat. I really appreciate the critical ears, thanks again optimus.
 
H-

Please hold comments, I'm going to add more of the bass track as Janet requested. But it will be later today. 

What type of hold should I put on my comments?

Nice vocals + great piano - good job!

Sounds good.   The Badfinger version was much different than the Harry Nilsson or Mariah Carey version.   This rendition captures the elements the original BF version while still sounding modern and original.  Like it.

Regards

I sure miss Janet up here.  I don't remember this one and I'm glad you remixed it.  I always loved this song and you did it justice.  Janet's piano is really nice!  Loved the vocals.