Wouldn't hurt to try different data and power connectors, then cables, on the new drive.
I recently had a power connector (from my power supply) burn out 3 HDs in quick succession. Literally fried the circuit boards. I didn't realize what was going on, and couldn't understand why the drives weren't being recognized. Then, when connecting the 3rd drive, I saw a wisp of smoke and smelled it burning.
Didn't lose any critical data, but losing three 4TB drives wasn't cheap (not to mention the cost to replace them).