• SONAR
  • The verdict: X2a is not good. Unstable and buggy as all heck (p.8)
2013/02/05 23:05:54
guitardood
WDI


Roots guy sounds like Bob. Nice! Sounded good streamed from my iPad iToy to my apple tv iToy so listening on my stereo system. 

Thanks WDI.


Best,
guitardood


2013/02/05 23:57:36
ampfixer
The newest C++ libraries on my system are the ones installed by Sonar X2a. It may be my imagination but I have had many more system issues since that install, as well as Issues in X2a tied to the Pro Channel and plug in manager. I'm going to see about a new machine tomorrow because I now want to isolate my Sonar system from everything else. 

I want my 1040ST back. Now that was a DAW.
2013/02/06 00:15:55
Bub
@ampfixer ... there is an update for C++ that came out on Jan 30th. Might want to check it out. I'm afraid to ... but maybe someone who knows more about this stuff can tell if it's safe to try.
2013/02/06 00:36:58
jscomposer
I'm just throwing in my 2 cents.....

Seen a lot of negative comments about Sonar over the years on this board, but I'm happy to report that I have been a fan of Cakewalk since day one (1992 in fact!). Sonar X2 Producer has been a dream for my workflow, X1 was great too. I use it on a daily basis and do some heavy orchestral soundtrack work with it, along with live recordings. The only time it crashed was when I used the 32bit version of Z3ta through J-Bridge (not sure why, but it doesn't like it). Honestly though, that is really it! Stable as hell, and always pulls through for me. And yes, I have tried/owned the other major DAW's and believe me, they all have their issues. I must admit, Digital Performer 8 looks pretty enticing, but I would only switch for the video features (plus it's $800).

I only have two suggestion for Sonar improvements:

1) Create a feature similar to Cubase 7's "Chord Track".

2) Develop more strength in the video features.

But really, these aren't even gripes! Anyways, just wanted to throw in a positive note to this thread.
2013/02/06 02:04:13
TS

"Was it a dual floppy or 10mb hard drive  ?" (/ AT286)

Dual floppy ; i bought a hard drive 10 Mo in 1985 (paid more than 5000 $ - 12000 FRF 1985) !

2013/02/06 02:21:40
Splat
Sonar patches call C++ updates. I wouldn't load another update till X2B whereby another C++ update may be installed.
2013/02/06 03:12:07
bapu
Did this fred win the race with GodsDanglingParticiples fred?
2013/02/06 05:07:19
guitardood
CakeAlexS


Sonar patches call C++ updates. I wouldn't load another update till X2B whereby another C++ update may be installed.

+1000 for this one.


Just to add a little "why" to this:  Say Cakewalk is using version 1.3.0231 of the C++ libraries to develop Sonar and distribute that version's redistributable with Sonar.   Next you install VSampler (just a name I picked out of thin air) which hasn't been updated in a while and was written to version 1.2.812 of the C++ libraries and installs that version of the redistributable with VSampler, could potentially cause a problem.  Also, say you install SlickerThanSlicedBread Compressor which uses version 1.3.4821 of the C++ libs and redistributes that with their product, it will overwrite the versions used to create sonar and potentially create a problem.  This is not Cake's fault, VSampler's fault or STSB Compressor's fault. 

This is Microsoft's fault.  This problem has been plaguing windows systems since Windows95 with MSVCP versions being downgraded by installing older software or upgraded by installing newer software to the point that it sometimes breaks Windows as well as some previously installed application. 

They have sort of resolved this, somewhat, by at least providing different libraries for their major releases (i.e. MSVCP5 for version 5, MSVCP6 for 6,etc)  but unfortunately with bug fixes and windows updates, even a supposed sideways move from MSVCP7.231 to MSVCP7.243 could potentially break software if either a bug that was counted on is now "fixed" or a new bug was introduced. 

And to the doubters that say "it is not possible that installing sonar (or any other application which updates system-wide libraries for that matter) broke windows", think again.   This particular scenario makes it completely possible if a driver manufacturer wrote their driver software with MSVCP7.231 and now after sonar, it is MSVCP7.243 or any other possible disparity between the lib used to develop vs the currently installed runtime lib version, could potentially break their driver and/or service which could potentially end up in a BSOD and prevent booting. 

Again, not Cake's fault, not the hardware or manufacturer's fault, but good ole Microsoft.  But don't believe me.  Just do a quick google search for "msvcrt version resolved" or "msvcp version resolved" and read through some of the 1.2 million results regarding this particular issue.  I've been complaining about this for quite a while that sandboxing apps to have their required libs in their own space and leave the \windows\system32 versions alone, would probably resolve at least 25% of the BSOD's of the Windows world.  As would differentiating between drivers required for windows to boot (a la safe-mode) and drivers for other pieces of hardware which should loaded in a separate memory space and not be allowed to crash the entire operating system.  If I need my files, I don't care if the bluetooth driver has a problem, just get me to my files.  Unfortunately, instead of concentrating on these difficult to solve problems, MS presents us with Metro. 

Sorry for another rant in the same thread.  Just a real hot button issue for me.  Hopefully somebody appreciated the little bit of enlightenment. 


Best,
guitardood


P.S.  My apologies to JamesYoYo for kind of hijacking your post.
2013/02/06 06:34:02
bobguitkillerleft
Much enlightenment ^ Thank You!
Bob
2013/02/06 11:05:47
Bub
jscomposer

The only time it crashed was when I used the 32bit version of Z3ta through J-Bridge (not sure why, but it doesn't like it).
Works fine here through J-Bridge ... must be your system.

Have you updated every single driver for every component of your computer? All the BIOS for your Motherboard, Video Card, and Audio Card?

System specs ... we need to see some system specs. Otherwise, we can't really help you.





Welcome to the forum jscomposer.
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account