• SONAR
  • Cakewalk charging for MP3 encoder activation - what a rip! (p.2)
2009/01/12 06:06:08
syrath
For the record, neither Cubase Essentials, nor Cubase Studio 4 come with mp3 encoding installed either. The license for MP3 encoders must be bought by the selling company for every disk sold that includes the encoder.

For instance, building in the licensed mp3 encoder into Sonar would add to the cost of producing Sonar, by the license, as well as incurring administrations costs to implement it, meaning that for every Cakewalk application you owned you would have lots of individual mp3 encoders.

If you had started working with Sonar from Version 1, and you also have, for example, Project5 versions 1 and 2, you would have had 10 encoders, costing about $200 (albeit over 8 years). Cakewalk give you the option of buying one encoder that will cover them all.

MP3 encoding is seen as more of a consumer (rather than a professional) process. Even 24 bit 44.1 khz wavefiles are relatively easy to transport (either in solid state devices or internet), and provide way more accurate recordings. Considering Sonar is a pro application why would you require to encode to a consumer format. Windows Media Audio is free and provides better than mp3 processing and is included in both Cubase and Sonar. Even FLAC compression (lossless) is certainly a preferred technique for compression, should it be required.
2009/01/12 06:08:21
Rothchild
This is the best walk through that I've seen yet to get MP3 working with Sonar:

http://www.thirdtake.com/2007/11/15/sonar-mp3-encoding-with-lame

Personally I think it's so easy to setup MP3 that I'm glad that I don't have to spend an extra 20bucks on Sonar to have something I can do myself, for free, in moments.

Cheers
Child
2009/01/12 08:06:43
SH
I'd gladly pay an extra $19 for Sonar if it just included the MP3 encoder.


Agreed, but I wouldn't want to pay it over and over for every upgrade. Sonar 8 may be the first for you but for me 8 upgrades x $19 is more than I want to spend for the same MP3 encoder.
2009/01/12 08:14:41
daveny5
Agreed, but I wouldn't want to pay it over and over for every upgrade. Sonar 8 may be the first for you but for me 8 upgrades x $19 is more than I want to spend for the same MP3 encoder.


You only have to pay for it once and then it works for all versions of Sonar.
2009/01/12 08:15:54
daveny5
he doesnt know its an old topic -- hes new -- chill


I apologize. Its just that this topic has been beaten to death.
2009/01/12 10:40:07
mmarton
It has been beaten to death but the above post about using Lame with Sonar should be a sticky here so new users can know. Fwiw, I'm NOT a new user and it still bugs me...
2009/01/12 11:07:35
soundchaser59

ORIGINAL: daveny5

he doesnt know its an old topic -- hes new -- chill


I apologize. Its just that this topic has been beaten to death.



Beaten to death from your perspective........not from mine.

Not attacking you, daveny, but.......

I am constantly amazed at the unbridled intolerance that is constantly and gratuitously tossed out on the red carpet by experienced music makers IN ALL FORUMS ONLINE, ON ALL TOPICS, not just here....... Harmony Central is particularly offensive in this way......
2009/01/12 11:10:38
dbmusic
I do appreciate the fact that WaveLab has the Lame encoder embedded. Though I wouldn't go the whole "absolutely clueless about how to treat customers with dignity" route, I've always thought that not embedding the encoder for the price of admission to professional DAW software a bit cheesy.
2009/01/12 11:11:47
Fog
webseed , appart from Lame.. you do know you can use i-tunes to encode tunes (not that I tried) and also MS has a thing to generate WMA..

mp3 is patented = chargable...

I dunno why people didn't switch to vorbis OGG , it's a shame more didn't take that up and it's patent free..
2009/01/12 13:04:43
artsoul

ORIGINAL: soundchaser59


ORIGINAL: daveny5

he doesnt know its an old topic -- hes new -- chill


I apologize. Its just that this topic has been beaten to death.



Beaten to death from your perspective........not from mine.

Not attacking you, daveny, but.......

I am constantly amazed at the unbridled intolerance that is constantly and gratuitously tossed out on the red carpet by experienced music makers IN ALL FORUMS ONLINE, ON ALL TOPICS, not just here....... Harmony Central is particularly offensive in this way......





Thats why I blocked him
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account