• Songs
  • How does this master sound?
2014/10/11 10:54:07
illerill
Hey guys,
I'm always second doubting things and I have a hard time trusting other people so I just wanted to check with you if the master of this track is good or not. I've raised the volume on the mix and I'm not letting you know which is the master and which is the mix.
 
Personally I think the master sounds better, but that doesn't really tell me if it's a good master or not.

https://soundcloud.com/user261211914/1a-1
https://soundcloud.com/user261211914/2a-1
 
Thanks in advance.
2014/10/11 13:13:12
Wookiee
Out of the two I find that 2a-1 has more air and openness in the feel/sound of the mix, listening on the A7x's.
2014/10/11 14:20:40
evadianepug
I would pick 2a-1 but they are both very close.  Sounds good. The rap is really pretty good. 
2014/10/11 18:32:33
illerill
I actually forgot which is the mastered one, lol. 
 
Oh well, regardless of that, isn't it problematic that the mix and master are very close to each other? I mean, my mastering engineer is asking me if I'm happy with it and it's really hard for me to tell because I don't really know what to expect. Over the years I've been using several different mastering engineers but I'm still pretty much clueless on what to expect from a master.
 
 
 
 
2014/10/12 12:45:35
drma173
Man this is really good song. 2 thumbs up man i heard both version. second version sound more level.
there are some back voice that i think doesnt fit well tho. I also commented on Soundcloud check it.
2014/10/12 22:33:31
Rimshot
The second mix is much better IMO.  The bass is tighter and the vocals seem to have more stereo spread.  There is a little more sparkle on top too.
2014/10/13 09:54:06
illerill
Thank you, guys.
 
Any of you got some really bad in ear phones or some bad speakers. Cuz I was listening to a couple of famous tracks and compared to them I feel my master is losing alot of quality in the crappy in ear phones I have. I'm feeling it's not as well adapted to crappy systems as it should be.
2014/10/13 13:14:53
Rimshot
That is funny illerill!  If your mix is losing quality on crappy systems and that is a concern, then you might have to make a decision on what audience is most important to you.  
All my stuff seems to sound crappy on crappy systems.
I at least try to make it sound good on an iPod or iPhone with $20 ear buds. Anything less than that I don't care.

2014/10/13 14:55:12
illerill
Yea, 20$ ear buds is what I have. I'm thinking that's what most people use.

I was just wondering if you could listen to the master with those crappy ear buds and give me your opinion on it. I already wrote to my mastering engineer about it but it's like I never feel confident enough to trust my own ears. 
2014/10/13 17:48:56
evadianepug
It is odd to work backwards and get rid of the good equipment so that we can tell you how it sounds on crappy equipment.  Nothin bad meant but I don't like to listen to music on laptop speakers or cheap earbuds, etc.  I certainly wouldn't critique on them.  Look up, illeril, not down.  You have talent.
12
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account