• Songs
  • 'On The Edge' (p.4)
2014/09/21 07:32:10
jamesg1213
Ah, here's Robbie, as expected...
 
The BandNineTeen
I'm picturing Mel Gibson as Robert the Bruce... "Freedom?" I don't think so... Scotland "the brave?"...etc...

 
Gibson 'portrayed' William Wallace, not Robert the Bruce. By the way, Wallace was a Scots nobleman, one of those privileged people you despise, not a lowly farmer as depicted in the movie by the xenophobic drunken Australian. All those pitched battles with kilts (kilts didn't exist until the 17th Century btw, Walllace lived 400 years before that) and facepaint? Never happened. Except Stirling Bridge...and Gibson decided not to put a bridge in it...

And after voting to remain a puppet of the crown? ..etc...Congrats on voting to remain subjects

 
Again....The referendum had nothing to do with the monarchy, Liz would have still been Queen of Scots, 'Yes' or 'No'. Google 'Balmoral'.
 
Like I say, keep it about the music, 'cos anything else seems to get you all muddle-headed



2014/09/21 21:40:08
Freddy J
Great song, sounds, and mix!
2014/09/23 14:59:53
stevec
+1 or more to everything above.   Everything it about it works really well.    And he does have a bit of that Gabriel whispery rasp, doesn't he.   
2014/09/24 16:15:36
jamesg1213
Freddy J
Great song, sounds, and mix!




Thanks Freddy!
2014/09/24 16:16:48
jamesg1213
stevec
+1 or more to everything above.   Everything it about it works really well.    And he does have a bit of that Gabriel whispery rasp, doesn't he.   




Thanks Steve. Yes, Tim gets that a lot He has a great voice.
2014/09/26 09:16:25
SteveStrummerUK
 
Great job gentlemen, particularly loving those cascading guitar parts James.
 
This one's a real beaut
 
 
 
 
 
 
Likewise Robby's views on the monarchy
2014/09/26 21:11:44
Rimshot
Had a long week.  Just got home and having a glass of wine listening to your song.  
It is brilliant.  Love everything about it.  Sounds great, playing is great.
Tim sang it great. 
All the creativity and fine mix.
Excellent job guys!
 
2014/09/27 03:20:09
jamesg1213
SteveStrummerUK
 
Great job gentlemen, particularly loving those cascading guitar parts James.
 
This one's a real beaut
 
 
 
 
 
 
Likewise Robby's views on the monarchy




Thanks Steve!
 
(don't encourage him)
2014/09/27 03:21:10
jamesg1213
Rimshot
Had a long week.  Just got home and having a glass of wine listening to your song.  
It is brilliant.  Love everything about it.  Sounds great, playing is great.
Tim sang it great. 
All the creativity and fine mix.
Excellent job guys!
 





Can't ask for better comments than those Jimmy!
2014/10/01 14:53:16
markno999
James,
 
Great work, how did you get Peter Gabriel to record those vocals;)   Everything is done superbly.  It could be a bit louder but this must be the original mix, not the master?  Anyway, had a few listens through and really like it...
 
Regards
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account