• SONAR
  • Sonar X2 Notation (p.16)
2012/08/06 19:55:30
relpomiraculous
Sibelius 7 First was cheap - $89 for Sibelius 6 First and $49 for the upgrade to Sibelius 7 First. The "First" series is a paired down version of the Full featured Sibelius software that has more features than I would ever need. And it does work with Sonar (rewire) already. http://www.sweetwater.com...etail/Sibelius6Firste/
2012/08/06 20:06:39
Beepster
@relpomiraculous... Now THAT is awesome and attainable. Thank you, kind sir. It has been bookmarked for later purchase.
2012/08/06 20:07:17
Michael Five
stevec


This topic is like the never-ending story...  
 
   
Does that mean that the staff view is eventually going to eat up the world unless we all start reading childrens books?


2012/08/06 20:10:03
Beepster
Can I be the boulder eating monster?
2012/08/06 21:27:12
stevec
Well, some might compare the SV to the Nothing. 
 
Perhaps what we need is a new name for it...
 
2012/08/06 21:54:21
trimph1
Giant Amorphous Protoplasm?
2012/08/06 22:49:58
myconsumerclub
the Blob
2012/08/06 23:49:28
sharke
Maybe the reason why Sonar's user base includes so few staff users is because music readers see no reason to buy it, precisely because it doesn't have decent notation functionality. 

I for one, think it's a shame. The trouble with PRV's is that it's like the keyboard version of guitar tabulature. It's basically there for people who cannot read music, or people who can play by ear. I played guitar by ear and from tab for years. When I finally knuckled down and learned to sight read, it was a revelation. Now as a classical guitar player I cannot even imagine learning (or composing) an intricate piece with guitar tab. It doesn't offer a good enough visual representation of the music. 

My main problem with PRV's is that I'm not a keyboard player. I can write music that's in my head, but the PRV is just nowhere near as good as traditional notation for setting down music swiftly and accurately, and keeping it organized in your head. If you have keyboard skills, then I imagine the brunt of your arranging is going to involve playing the parts on the keyboard and then touching them up in the PRV later. Without keyboard skills, you're reduced to inserting the notes on the PRV from scratch. It's just so much easier to do that on a proper stave. 

I think that by offering a good quality notation view, or by offering a plugin for a price, Cakewalk would be greatly increasing the potential user base of Sonar. 
2012/08/07 00:03:52
stevec
If you have keyboard skills, then I imagine the brunt of your arranging is going to involve playing the parts on the keyboard and then touching them up in the PRV later. Without keyboard skills, you're reduced to inserting the notes on the PRV from scratch.

 
Good point...   I do play keys, so have never realy thought about it much.   I may sometimes manually write parts into the PRV, but I usually do play them in and edit afterwards as needed. 
 
My hope for the SV is simple: Make it as simple to enter and modify notes as the PRV when it comes to snap and duration. 
 
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account