clintmartin
Audio Technica ATH-M50's is what I have, and what I would recommend.
I've compared and contrasted lots of headphones for EM's roundups over the years. The ATH-M50s are great value and I would recommend them. But every set of headphones has a different "talent." The ATH-M50s have goodoverall balance, but AKG outperforms them for high frequencies. Interestingly, I tested two Shure headphones and the less expensive one was better and more accurate for mixing than the more expensive one.
Headphones are sometimes bass-shy, and don't give an accurate representation of what's going on in the low end. I have a pair of Beats and use those as a reality check for what's going on at 100Hz and below. When I need to mix on headphones, I set up the mix on the ATH-M50s, then check the highs with AKGs and the lows with Beats.
I tend not to like Sony MDR headphones that much for mixing because the midrange pops too much for my tastes. But for DJing, they're great because you can hear what's happening over the ambient noise better. Ultrasones are good consumer phones but not realistic enough for mixing.
The biggest surprise to me have been (don't laugh) Monster's Turbine Pro earbuds (c'mon, I told you not to laugh). I took them on a trip to Europe once to listen to music on the plane but ended up doing rough mixes of some videos on them in hotel rooms. I of course expected to have to tweak the mixes when I got back to my studio, but was shocked that the mixes translated
perfectly. I didn't have to touch a thing. These were the Copper model with the flat response, though, not the Gold model with the hyped highs and lows.
This is an
older article, but you might find it interesting. I did a newer roundup on headphones for EM, but can't find it.