• Songs
  • New Song - Cassandra
2014/08/24 14:21:30
ruralrocker2010
Hey Guys - would love some general feedback on this song.
 
https://soundcloud.com/joshua-barnes/cassandra-joshua-barnes
 
Feel free to comment on;

The lyrics
The Melody
The Instrumentation
The Mix
2014/08/24 15:15:21
Rimshot
Hey Joshua,
I like the song and arrangement.  I think the mix is too trashy sounding.  Very brash to me.  I am hearing distortion and maybe too much frequency staturation ( like using the Saturation knob turned up too much).
I would start with a basic clean mix of the primary instruments, drop your lead vocal in, and then start applying effects and stuff.  
 
Rimshot
2014/08/24 17:57:18
markno999
Joshua,
 
Good song and arrangement.   the vocal performance is very good.    I agree with Rimshot regarding the mix, maybe a bit over-saturated and over compressed but still a nice job overall.
 
Regards
2014/08/24 18:47:23
RussjWhite
Good singing and song. nice instruments too, I like what they are doing, drifting in and out.
Rimshot is spot on with regards to the mix.
2014/08/24 21:48:56
Guitarpima
I like the song. I concur with the comments on the mix. I'll never understand why people use saturation knobs. I guess it's subjective but I don't care for the sound.
2014/08/25 03:17:01
Larry Jones
Great track. Sounds like after last call, after closing, whiskey and cigarettes. I don't care about saturation, and your fans won't either. This is dangerous rock'n'roll and it should be dirty. You might want to try louder drums...
2014/08/25 07:21:37
Hemul
Listened to this at work through a low quality headset - for that at least the mix worked very well. Enjoyed the song, excellent vocals, I don't have anything critical to say, except maybe that the end seemed a bit abrupt.
 
 
2014/08/25 19:31:25
ruralrocker2010
I love this community - I'll respond to each of you individually shortly!
2014/08/26 09:01:58
rebel007
Love the song. Bit of low rumble that could be high passed, not sure where it's coming from. I agree that everything's a little over compressed and up front for me. The vocal work is awesome, I have envy regarding your voice.
Did I mention that I love the song, a hit if ever I heard one.
2014/08/27 16:28:55
Lynn
I think rebel hit it right on the head.  It could use a little breathing room, dynamic-wise, but, overall I like the arrangement and the way sounds just slide into the mix.  Way cool.  I also like the f/x in this, though you could try some different mix levels.  Your songwriting continues to impress me!
12
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account