Thanks Eric for giving those 2 mix examples !
I'm far from being a sound engineer, but listening through Sony 7506 headphones (certainly not a monitor reference as valuable as real monitors, but I know them perfectly), the "old" mix sounds much more open, with a very good balance and a more pleasant sound, in comparison with the New mix which is louder but "harshy", without air : it seems that the cymbals and the crashes are much more tamed in the old mix and that allows the other instruments to breathe.
No offense at all concerning your mastering skills; maybe it depends from your personal taste and decision to confer a particular color to your mix.
But I have to admit that concerning the old mix, I cannot believe it ! What a real treat to hear a track that sounds like that ! It's true that the name of Bob Katz is a big reference in the mastering domain; do you know with which tools he made the mastering process ?
this make me think about the "danger" of having a vast number of plugins which allows to "enhance", embellish, inflate, flattering frequencies and it results with a less natural and more artificial agressive sound. It is also relative to the plug algorithm quality and I hope the new X2 Console Emu does not deliver too much harshness, even at low settings.
Eric, concerning the track "It's going to be alright" ,I find the composition, the arrangements, melodies,... everything is very nice/ perfect, and I love it (I am a musician in Gipsy King style bands and I especially appreciate the lead guitar playing :Congratulation for your playing game technique and natural feeling) Anyway bravo for your talent and thank you again for sharing your work.
Pierre