• Coffee House
  • Tal Wilkenfeld from Australia, Best female Bass Player ? (p.5)
2016/03/22 06:53:06
ston
Am I the only person on the planet who doesn't like Jeff Beck?  Never seen what all the fuss is about.
 
Got to dash, I'm running a bit late for my public stoning...
2016/03/22 07:19:54
craigb
I know a couple of guys who never "got" Jeff Beck.  Then they watched him play in something like the Live at Ronnie Scotts video.  They may still not care for his music, but their appreciation of his abilities went way up.
2016/03/22 10:57:54
batsbrew
ston
Am I the only person on the planet who doesn't like Jeff Beck?  Never seen what all the fuss is about.
 
Got to dash, I'm running a bit late for my public stoning...


the answer:
 
yes.
 

2016/03/22 14:11:11
michaelhanson

2016/03/22 14:14:51
michaelhanson

2016/03/22 14:26:14
michaelhanson
batsbrew
ston
Am I the only person on the planet who doesn't like Jeff Beck?  Never seen what all the fuss is about.
 
Got to dash, I'm running a bit late for my public stoning...


the answer:
 
yes.
 



 

 
Like Jeff's Strat!
2016/03/22 17:24:04
bayoubill
Jeff Beck is one of those guys with beaucoup chops and an ear doing sounds that slip past ya if you're not paying attention. It's well worth the time to take a couple of weeks to study his style. You will learn something!
Unlike dating which yields no benefits! 
 
LOoking at Tal helps me forget       Forget       forget       forget  dating experiences and helps me maintain my fantasy world where I Am master!
2016/03/22 17:47:50
Beepster
There is also the fact that perhaps for younger players listening to Beck it seems like he isn't doing anything all that special or unique.
 
Thing is though... he was the originator of a LOT of those licks, riffs and deedleedoops.
 
A lot of his fancier stuff reminds me of Satriani (and Vai)... who I listened to quite a bit when I first started playing. Of course the Satch came MUCH later than Beck and Satch taught Vai. Once I got my hands on some Beck stuff it blew me away he was doing those things so much earlier.
 
Then there is Zappa who did a lot of similar stuff when he soloed. Not sure if Beck influenced him or vice versa or if they both came to it all organically on their own (it's really just modal mayhem).
 
Whatevs... Beck is kind of the grandpappy of that spacey, modal slickster rock sound... and he does it, IMO, in a more mature, tasteful, less flashy way than those other guys (not including Zappa Sr in that... he was something different).
 
That is totally ignoring his blues stuff which is a whole 'nother style and goes waaaay further back.
 
His supporting material is also much more inclusive and tasteful than Satch/Vai too who's backing bands are mostly just there for them to shred over.
 
This of course can be seen in the vid above and his inclusion of Tal in the band in the first place. She's actually much flashier/more physically proficient than he is IMO. He's actually kind of sloppy compared to her.
 
Meh... he was doing his thing before I was even born (WAY before) so my perspective/history is likely just as skewed as other youngin's. I'd imagine listening to Beck back in the day would have been utterly mind blowing.
2016/03/22 18:53:24
eph221
I like anything that's composed well, including a guitar solo.  Jeff Beck does a great job of that.  If you're a guitar player listening to another guitar player, you should envy *it's* creativity not just push it away.  Shredding is just like a word salad.  Think Sarah Palin versus JFK.  When I hear lousy solos, I think of Sarah.
2016/03/22 19:06:29
Beepster
Weeeell... I'm an unrepentant shredder and have been for pretty much the whole time I've played. However I'd like to think I've learned to build up to a shred in a tasteful way. Not just wank for the sake of wanking.
 
I do also play a plethora of styles that are totally unshred related. I just generally prefer fast music... because I'm a spazz. I pride myself more on my rhythm playing though. There is so much more interesting stuff that can be done with rhythm guits.
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account