2012/09/18 21:03:53
evansmalley
After thinking about this for a while, I would guess that a simple form of overall vari-speed, like is used in Reaper, would be the easiest and most functional update for Sonar. I'd guess it uses a basic vari-ing of the sampling frequency, like ADATS did, which Anderton mentioned. Having separate Vari-Pitch and Vari-Tempo probably would have a lot of good things about being able to use them separately, but the audible artifacts of those processes would probably be a problem. Still would be nice to have as an option. At least there's audiosnap already. And some easy ways to change the pitch of a clip- but they sound kinda funky to me in the way that they have artifacts and weirdnesses- kinda ruins the FIDELITY of the sound!

The sweet thing about overall vari-speed, like it's done in Reaper, is that it keeps pitch and speed proportional and doesn't crush or stretch the audio in a weird way, which can create undesirable weirdnesses in the sound. 

 
2012/09/18 21:08:19
Jeff Evans
The point is can Sonar provide varispeed easily and the answer is No simple as that. Can other programs do it and the answer is yes and very easily. That should be noted. As usual because Sonar cannot do something or do it easily many Sonar users think no other program can or should be able to do it as well.

Reaper does it very easily and so does Studio One and it does it all live and in real time. (with superb sound quality) As I have explained earlier. Any single audio event or group of audio events can simply be played back at any interval from 1 to 24 semitones either above or below concert pitch. Not only that but anywhere from 0 to 100 cents as well in either direction. 

Tempo stays the same of course but you only have to move the tempo parameter in Studio One and every audio file will easily speed up or slow down accordingly. What more could you want. So entire arrangements can be simply and very easily altered tuning (and tempo) wise to allow for a difficult instrument tuning wise to be recorded. (didgeridoo is great example of this) They have probably allowed for this from day one though in their planning and execution. Just adding it on to an existing program may not be as easy as many think. 

To be honest though even though I use a program that does all of this very easily I have rarely done it ever. And so to Sonar's defence I think that putting a program down because it cannot do this easily is also a bit unfair too as I am sure there are many features in X2 say that are very worthwhile from many other workflow points of view and far outweigh the varispeed option. But it does also mean if you are really wanting and needing to do this a lot because you are someone that is involved with recording a lot of things that are not normally tuned to concert then some further investigation into what DAW's do it easily and well may be warranted.

Also to those people who are talking about people and how they may conduct themselves on this forum remember my signature. You are of poor mind when you are doing that. Stick to the ideas instead, it is much more interesting and valuable.

2012/09/18 22:19:19
yorolpal
And really great minds don't have time to futz with any of this horse hockey.
2012/09/18 23:22:45
trimph1
Equine Plumage!!!
2012/09/19 07:55:19
The Maillard Reaction
*
2012/09/19 08:04:23
Jonbouy

 
Draw leaf or refectory?
 
Why major on an aspect that doesn't work when you've been given many suggestions that do?  i.e. wide band pitch shifting.
 
Audacity even will do it for free.
 
Being as you like the idea of flexing a single knob try this. (again)
 
http://www.quikquak.com/Prod_Pitchwheel.html
 
btw Sonar doesn't have varispeed just now, in case you were unaware of it, most of us would like to see it at some point but for the simple limited problem you gave there are many options available already that shouldn't impact on your workflow to a greater extent than labouring on a lost cause here.
 
Take your pick, or carry on swinging it.  Your choice.
 
HTH
 
2012/09/19 08:19:47
Funkybot
Because this thread has seems to have gone off track on odd conversations about tuning or things other than true varispeed...I quote myself (with some added insight):

...Varispeed would allow one to:  

1. Create harmonies they couldn't otherwise sing (pitch the track down 2 steps for a moment, sing the harmony along with the now pitched-down track, pitch everything back up - boom a high harmony you coulnd't otherwise sing). The Beatles did this all the time. The change in timbre was just part of the sound (see Paperback Writer). 

2. Create cool effects just due to timbre changes. Example: The "In My Life" (The Beatles) piano solo. That odd sound is a grand piano that played the solo an octave lower, then was sped up and therefore pitched back up an octave. The pitch shifting and formant changes due to the speeding up created that weird harpsichord like tone. Also, George Martin would have been unable to play a part that fast at full speed, hence why the track needed to be slowed down in the first place.  

3. Smooth automatable varispeed would allow for cool pitch bending effects. A good example is the intro string part to The Flaming Lips "Race for the Prize," those sliding strings are all done with a tape varispeed.  
2012/09/19 08:24:00
Jonbouy
Funkybot, nobody is disputing that 'varispeed' would be cool. (and it is where it is available)
 
Sonar doesn't have it just now, there are many methods of skinning Mikes cat though which are simple enough for even him to perform.
 
Trust me I use a couple of applications where it truly is available but that isn't enough in itself to have made Sonar redundant.   You get that tools that do the job you require if you need them badly enough.
 
Mike just likes to see the menu so he can order something that isn't on it, and then complain about the restaurant rather than eat someplace where his tastes are catered for.
2012/09/19 08:47:04
Funkybot
Jonbouy


Funkybot, nobody is disputing that 'varispeed' would be cool. (and it is where it is available)
 
Sonar doesn't have it just now, there are many methods of skinning Mikes cat though which are simple enough for even him to perform.
 
Trust me I use a couple of applications where it truly is available but that isn't enough in itself to have made Sonar redundant.   You get that tools that do the job you require if you need them badly enough.
 
Mike just likes to see the menu so he can order something that isn't on it, and then complain about the restaurant rather than eat someplace where his tastes are catered for.
Understood. For now, I keep a Reaper license around for when I want to varispeed something but use Sonar for most other things. 

2012/09/19 10:25:47
evansmalley
For now, I keep a Reaper license around for when I want to varispeed something but use Sonar for most other things. 



Yeah, me too. But it's SO much more of a pain to work in than Sonar, in my opinion!
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account