• SONAR
  • Poll: Is DSF symphonic strings worth the uncertainty? (p.2)
2012/09/19 12:25:45
synkrotron
lol... PowerChords methinks haha

All part of the experimentation process. If something doesn't work as expected then try something else.

I've downloaded mine but not installed it yet. Might get time Friday night to have a play and see what peeps are saying :)
2012/09/19 13:13:09
konradh
Are they substantially different or better than the SI-Strings that come with Producer?  I don't use the SI-Strings because I have other things, but they are OK.
2012/09/19 13:27:04
Beepster
I'll be fired up in a little bit, konradh. Where would I find SI strings? Is that part of DimPro or something else? I'd imagine it's probably better though. There are a ton of variations and room/mic settings from onstage to back of the hall. It is quite powerful.
2012/09/19 13:28:34
Beepster
And really if you're planning on getting X2 at some point anyway you might as well just snag it now even if you don't want to install it right away.
2012/09/19 13:40:45
PilotGav
I purchased the Garritan Pocket Orchestra a couple of years ago when it was on sale through Cakewalk.

Should I bother with DSF? I really can't afford to order today, however if DSF is better (I know this is subjective) than GPO - I may be able to get help.

I would never do a full orchestra composition, but I enjoy  having "realistic" sounding strings to lay underneath my more mainstream work.

Thanks!

Gavin
2012/09/19 13:58:28
synkrotron
Beepster


Where would I find SI strings? 

If you have X1 Producer then there are four SI virtual synths, each start the those letters. I've tried the bass guitar one and it's not too bad, if you pass it through guitar rig and stuff. I've not tried the other three.
2012/09/19 14:05:55
subtlearts
The strings are... umm... OK, in a word. They are better than the demo makes them sound, but that's not saying much. There are a bunch of total throwaway filler patches with not particularly great or imaginative sounding effects put on them, which is about as useful as a chocolate teapot; I am personally quite able to apply a vanilla phaser to my string sound if I think it would sound good, and I suspect that I might not be alone. The straight up ensemble and section patches are decent, but as others have said nothing to make the Vienna folks tremble (heh, I'll be living in Vienna this winter for 5 months!). I haven't A/B'd them against the SI ones or, for that matter, the Vienna subset that comes with Kontakt, which is what I tend to use  if I'm going for realism (if not, I'm as likely to use Mellotron or retro synth strings as anything else). My gut feeling is that the DSF ones are kind of somewhere in between the two. 

If you're really on the fence about whether to upgrade at all, I wouldn't let the bonus sway you unless you are really hard up for string sounds. However, if you feel like you'll probably upgrade at some point anyway (it's hard for me to see why anyone wouldn't unless you're changing platforms) I doubt the price will ever go down, and this is a little perk for getting in on the ground floor. There will probably be other special offers later, mind you - other freebies, whatever, but I personally can't see the price getting any lower. Then again, I've been wrong before!
2012/09/19 14:23:35
stevec
Where would I find SI strings?

 
SI = the Studio Instruments series: Strings, Electric Piano, Bass and Drums.
 
2012/09/19 14:34:10
bapu

Is DSF symphonic strings worth the uncertainty?



Is it just me or aren't these mutually exclusive issues?



You either want to be an early adopter or not.

And if you do you either want the strings for free or you don't.

Being an early adopter does not require the pre-purchase (last day today).
2012/09/19 14:44:12
Beepster
Ah okay. I thought it might be a Studio Instruments thing but didn't realize there was one for orchestral strings. Cheers.
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account