0.Many of these are not actually purchases. I typically get musical goodies at Christmas from my wife (yes - some marriages actually work and we still like each other after 8 years), so many of these, she purchased.
Best:
VDrums and all the upgrades - most recently the TD-20 brain, which I really Love for its variety, simplicity, midi capabilities, etc
Sonar 6PE (or prev versions, but so far, of course, 6 is the best)
My Line6 Stuff - I've got a variax 500 guitar, 705 Bass (5-string), the Toneport UX2 and the Gearbox VST plugs - I just like all their stuff, and there's always something to dislike, but I generally don't find it in these. Their quality surpasses my abilities, being primarily a drummer.
Contour Shuttle Pro V1, when it worked right in XP with the "old Sonar plugin"
Sonik Synth 2 - Lots of good sounds (though some a few bugs) for just about any keyboard/synth sound you could generally need, with lots of tweaking options and stacking, evolving things that can be done with it. It's fun just to play around with it, even if not record. Sample Tank 2 is in this same class, though I think I like the sound library of Sonik Synth2 better, the interface and updates are better for ST, which can open the SS2 library anyway, and SS2 has a new version now that has 16 parts multi-timbral, etc.
So-so:
BCF2000 - I generally really like this and want to like it. I need to make some overlay templates so I don't FEEL like I'm using something so generic - and so infrquently that it's always a bit of a learning curve to get into again, so I fall back to the mouse and worsen the cycle.
Worst:
Contour Shuttle Pro - Under Vista, it isn't as cool because a. if Sonar is not in focus, it starts to control another app, which I can't seem to stop it from doing, and if I could, it still would do nothing instead of controlling Sonar unless Sonar was in focus, and b. because the shuttle/jog can't be set to a resolution below "measure" and it just moves to fast that way and not to the places I usually like to shuttle to - like a measure and a half before I want to start recording to give pre-roll and an even measure of the tune before I have to go - or something like that.
added: this is not THAT bad - I just don't really have a lot of crappy purchases. I guess the Peavey 1600x fader controller was a bad one - the product was ok, but the usefulness of non-motorized faders and nothing like ACT around, it just sat there.