I used to use every Bass amp sim you could think of until I went for a more realistic approach. (no not an amp)
Running the bass direct and using EQ, Compression and some saturation. there's your amp sim right there.
Any Sim will introduce characteristics but will also introduce noise as well.
I want the cleanest bass sound I can get. This mean a direct signal and applying FX. that's it.
I typically layer bass tracks though. some playing octaves, sometimes a distorted retro clav or pianos lows mixed in to create a bass sound as a whole. this takes practice and caution. If the layered tracks fall out of synch they become reversed polarity and cancel out the others signal thus sounding thin in areas.
Guitar amp Sims are another ballgame all together, more often than not your looking to reproduce an authentic tube sound. So a good amp sim is critical for those areas. Bass though, I have found its better left as clean as possible with only compression and EQ (and some saturation). Below is a list of FX and methods I use for hard rock by they still apply across the board:
*Do not use all at once. these are different methods to choose but I typically use 3 to 4 bass tracks in all.1 main stringed bass guitar track and 2 or 3 alternatives mixed in a bit lower then the main bass track. Recording:- Bass direct in to a DI box
- Alesis 3630 Compressor 4:1 ratio using
only light compression to round of spikes (go very light)
- New strings or boiled string for a snappy sound.
Plug ins:- Softubes Grand Summit (EQ / Compressor)
- Softubes Saturation knob
- Cakewalks CA2A PC Module Compressor
- Cakewalks Percussion strip (EQ / Compressor)
Tracking:- Double your tracks using a soft synth like SI Bass. use a higher frequency snappy setting.
- Double your tracks using a soft synth like Toontracks EZ Keys Grand piano (only the lower range of piano)
- Double your tracks using a soft synth like Toontracks EZ Keys Retro Clavinet (Distorted preset)
- Double your tracks using 2 more Bass tracks. Not played through the whole song but only on choruses, bridges ,exc..
(play these parts on octaves).
This method can be heard here:
https://soundcloud.com/charlie-roy/seven