When you do a cover of such a classic rock song.... man everybody knows that song.... you are putting yourself up against the best of the best with this cover..... Eddie and the boys were world class....
...... I think you guys got fairly close to the feel and spirit of the original..... maybe around 90% of the way there.
the drums sound like they are not exactly a part of the mix. too dry. perhaps too much up front. Snare sounds too something..... not right.
the mix has a certain stiff feel about it....(yeah there's a chance to turn a phrase in classic Robby fashion)
Covering the vox.... I would not even attempt it, but you did a reasonably good job on it.
The playing is quite good. Nice work on the song. Just a few minor tweeks to get it to swing in that VH groove a bit better.....