rebel007 - much thanks, I appreciate your ear.
Jamesg1213 - thanks, I am getting the feeling the sounds are unusual, which I didn't expect.
Wookie - that's precisely what I was going for...a more spacey mix, lots of room for the parts.
Scottytunes - I have been getting that same...response, different vibes...took me by surprise actually.
speedtom - No, I don't mind that at all, and was exactly what I expected really - to stand out as a radio friendly commercial type thing.
I'll be honest, I'm disappointed at the overall response, or lack thereof. I know everyone in here can relate. I guess I just blew it on this one.
I've always prided myself on knowing what people want to hear - and when I write long, windy songs, with an emphasis on music over vocals, meandering structures over radio friendly structures, I know full well that I am challenging the listener. So I've always accepted the lack of enthusiasm, and select audience I get as a result of that - has always been expected and has never bothered me at all.
But this time, I purposely set out to do something simple and radio friendly. And I am
completely dumbfounded at the response I'm getting - not so much here, but on other song boards. I thought I had a great song here that was accessible to the modern ear, but man, I can tell that people are just not digging it. And I'm clueless to what is happening. Maybe I'm just completely out of touch. I don't know.
I like to learn from my mistakes. And I'm so lost here, that I don't know what to take from this, what to learn. My wife says I'm too influenced by Mars Volta and that this song is too much of a Jekyll and Hyde. I don't hear it, honestly. But maybe she's right? (pst..nobody tell her I said she might be right about something, she'll never let me forget it, ha ha!)