bitflipper
schwa
My question is: If you like to use S-type tools in your channels, do you prefer Waves, Prochannel, or something else? If so, why?
My question is: can anyone really tell the difference in a blind listening test?
I can't distinguish, for example, between the ProChannel compressor and Cytomic The Glue without peeking. While official SSL emulations and The Glue each have features the other lacks, they both cover the same basic territory. But for some reason, popular opinion generally prefers The Glue in polls.
Its a great question really because when you think about it, It all about the code. I believe we are coming to a rock bottom in world of Digital recording and there's not much room to expand (sonically speaking).
Sure there will always be new features added but until a new fidelity is invented the only thing really becoming more creative are GUI's.
EDIT: I wanted to add a bit more to my previous comment-
I really wanted to disagree with you on this Bitflipper. because when I listen closely to the Waves SSL bus compressor, I honestly do feel like I hear a difference from the others. But I have to be honest with myself, im not sure there is a great big difference and if I were to blind test them I can not say I would be able to tell (except for the Analog feature on the Waves SSL, I better be able to hear that or everything I've been believing about Analog is a lie

)
We have all been around the block and lived through the hardware age where each different piece of gear had its own unique characteristics. Wheather that be tubes or the Diodes. With the computer age, there is only mere cloning or mimicking if you will of that classic gear (which they do a mighty fine job if I say so myself).
But when it comes right down to it, we are all playing on the same table now with the exception of Audio interfaces and outboard gear. So to wrap up this very long reply to your question... No I don't think I would be able to tell the difference between good quality plug ins. But that's not to say some plug ins are not more creative than others in their own way.