That does seem to the the general consensus :D. I actually have a bunch, I have Breverb 2, RC 24, RC 48, Trueverb, Sonitus, and BlueVerb in the synthetics and Spaces, IR-L, Reflektor, and REmatrix Solo in the IR based. Now I have H-Reverb too, of course.
 
The issue I have, which is a minor one, is that I use reverb for blend and space. I like to put all my instruments together in a real space, specifically a nice concert hall. However I like the ability to a synthetic reverb to sync the reverberation to the tempo of the song. So, if I could find a synthetic that sounded like a real hall and could od that, great.
 
Thus far though, none work. They all work well for specific things, but putting them over everything ends up being problematic, particularly for the bass drum. It just ends up splatty in hall spaces. You tighten it up and it works fine, but that's not what I want.
 
So I thought maybe H-Reverb. Nope. Oh well. :P

At the risk of sounding hypocritical, I have to note that ValhallaRoom's "Large Room" mode does a fine job on percussive parts, including kicks.

I have breeze and aether from 2Caudio. I have demoed as many synthetic reverb as possible and tried them all on vocals, strings, piano and drums. And for my taste (pianist) Breeze beat Valhalla by a mile. I could not relate to all the hype about Valhalla Room. (Please don't kill me VR fans).
 
I bought Breeze for about 74.99 during Christmas sale 3 years ago. I like it so much that I bought Aether as an upgrade (sort of) a year later.
 

Sounds like you need IKMultimedia's CSR to add to your reverb repertoire.

mudgel
Sounds like you need IKMultimedia's CSR to add to your reverb repertoire.

I'm going a little off topic here, but this is interesting information I thought everyone would like to know:
 
The IK Classic Studio Reverb was developed by Relab!
 
http://www.soundonsound.com/news?NewsID=13056
 
"Relab Development are a Danish company that specialise in plug-in coding. They were founded in 2004 and, while you may not have heard their name before, you’ll almost certainly have heard (or heard of) the fruits of their labours: IK Multimedia’s Classik Studio Reverb and SSL’s X-Verb (for their Duende DSP processors) are but two of the plug-ins they’ve had a hand in.
Now Relab have released the first plug-in under their own name, and it promises to be something rather special. The LX480 is, as its name implies, a model of the revered Lexicon 480L, one of the most iconic digital reverbs ever, and one that still gets used today despite being over 20 years old!"
 
 
Now back on topic:
 
The OP (Sycraft) should try out the Relab LX480 Hall. It might have the sound you are looking for.
 http://www.relab.dk/
 
 
 
 
 
 

Still somewhat off topic, are all four CSR verbs recommended? I have Hall and Plate, but didn't get Room or Inverse. And a bit further off topic, just got another oldie, PSP EasyVerb. Now that's a sweet Lolita.

mudgel
Sounds like you need IKMultimedia's CSR to add to your reverb repertoire.

When all else fail, CSR always seems to work on drums and percussions for me. I rarely use it, but I like to know that it's there if I need it.