2016/01/10 10:31:44
DeeringAmps
What is actually covered by copyright?
Top line melody and lyrics; isn't it?
I guess IF the bass line IS the melody its covered?
Too much is a stake, in the case of Estate of R. California vs Led Zeppelin, to settle out of court?
Not near as "cut and dried" as Page/Plant's "fair use" of many Dixon, Johnson, et al. lyrics...
 
T
2016/01/10 12:04:56
bitflipper
At least we can all sing Happy Birthday now with legal impunity.
2016/01/10 14:08:57
ampfixer
I think the USA should be renamed as lawyerland. There are more legal practitioners per capita there than any place on the planet. Everyone sues everyone eventually. It's a twisted version of 6 degrees of separation. 
2016/01/10 20:47:40
kennywtelejazz
Well there are 3 tunes I grew up listening too that there ain't nobody in this world is gonna be able to copy the changes of and call their own with out getting a can of whip a$$ from a lawyer ...
Aqualung , Smoke on The Water and Iron Man ....
Dem 3 tunes I still listen to occasionally 
 
Kenny
2016/01/10 23:00:09
mixmkr
that chromatic descending line is pretty much melodic jazz 101, with the tonic, maj7, etc, etc...  Ends you on that groovy minor 6 chord
2016/01/11 11:43:38
bapu
michaelhanson
I think Bapu owns Am.

The beauty is that I'm the only juan who can play that note. It's a mystery to all others.
2016/01/11 12:15:42
bitflipper
Here I always thought Smoke on the Water was just Proud Mary in reverse.
2016/01/11 13:53:23
DeeringAmps
"From Bob Dylan to Steve Jobs, he says our most celebrated creators borrow, steal and transform"
Good artists copy, great artists steal.
Someone famous said that; didn't he?
 
t
2016/01/11 14:02:23
bapu
bitflipper
Here I always thought Smoke on the Water was just Proud Mary in reverse.


And here I thought "Space Oddity" was just "Space Truckin'" slowed down.
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account