2015/12/22 02:11:12
kakku
How to get comments on songs, the age old question. I really don't have many ideas except trying to be too funny won't work. Good songs help, ofc. Commenting other people's songs might help. Having a good story for the song might help also. Having good lyrics might also help. Especially if they are put available on the thread. And now I hope somebodies with good ideas to step in to give more good tips on this matter.
Edit:what might be bad is change the song you are already sent to be listened to others for any reason.
2015/12/22 03:51:00
jamesg1213
Definitely comment on other people's stuff, it will be reciprocated
 
Thank people if they comment, individually if possible.
 
Don't flood the first page with tunes, that's asking too much from people.
 
Get involved in collabs from time to time.
 
Don't remove the song/tune if it doesn't immediately get comments, give it time.
2015/12/22 03:58:25
kakku
jamesg1213
Definitely comment on other people's stuff, it will be reciprocated
 
Thank people if they comment, individually if possible.
 
Don't flood the first page with tunes, that's asking too much from people.
 
Get involved in collabs from time to time.
 
Don't remove the song/tune if it doesn't immediately get comments, give it time.

Well, I have some removals done not because instant comments but because I felt it was the wrong song after all. And I have also put too many songs on the first page. I need more control in these things, gotta think things through. Good. More tips if possible. This thread can be helpful to many, but not sure.
2015/12/22 07:46:39
Beagle
jamesg1213
Definitely comment on other people's stuff, it will be reciprocated
 
Thank people if they comment, individually if possible.
 
Don't flood the first page with tunes, that's asking too much from people.
 
Get involved in collabs from time to time.
 
Don't remove the song/tune if it doesn't immediately get comments, give it time.


James has nailed it.
2015/12/22 08:05:42
kakku
OK, I admit that I am a restless soul. But I have not takem songs off because of noT getting instantly feedback. I made it because I have troubles deciding which tune too put up. Instead I have put too often tunes up that I regret. Erroneously I thought it would not matter as it is not mandatory to answer to every time. But I am restless and that is one of my bad attributes. It does not look nice if I all the time try to get comments. Continues when I get out of this mall. H*******ish mall.
2015/12/22 08:12:45
jamesg1213
kakku
OK, I admit that I am a restless soul. But I have not takem songs off because of noT getting instantly feedback.



I wasn't inferring that you did, but some people do, and it's disappointing to find an 'empty' thread.
2015/12/22 08:23:11
kakku
jamesg1213
kakku
OK, I admit that I am a restless soul. But I have not takem songs off because of noT getting instantly feedback.



I wasn't inferring that you did, but some people do, and it's disappointing to find an 'empty' thread.

Well it looks like I did and I am not trying to accuse you of saying that it just happens from my side too easily. It is my doing that I overload the forums and even this thread is going a bit in the wrong direction. Well I did start it semi serious but t got serious. I wish I could restart this forum stay but I would probably do it again.
2015/12/22 08:30:45
kakku
I meant to type something More but I accidentally pushed reply button. And now I forgot it. Well it prolly wasn't important. Gotta eat next. And then bak.
2015/12/22 10:00:22
Moshkito
Hi,
 
I think it depends on the situation.
 
I'm not looking for attention, but letting people know it's there is not asking for attention ... it mostly just an awareness thing, letting people know it's there if they are interested sometime.
 
I come from a literary huge thing, and I don't want to be a part of it, because there were way too many saidistic mofo's involved that were not pleasant to deal with, and we're still dealing with removing those leeches from our scalps ... but, in general, if the material is good, and has its points and abilities, I sincerely doubt that many folks will fail to get a look at it, and learn something. With one huge exception. Today, with the Internet, the literary side of things is more difficult and the cynicism involved in many of these boards, makes it difficult to define/appreciate those who are good, from the rest. And it all becomes a "favorite", which is not quite exactly the standard for good, bad or best and a hit. It does help.
 
For a long time, in the early days of the Internet/Media, doing some alarming things were just what the doctor ordered. For example, some film makers would do this or that and when it would be released the Catholic Church would open its mouth and that move would get a million people watching it. And this finally hit its zenith, when they went after "Deep Throat" and it became one of the first videos ever made and it sold millions, for a very badly made (and cheap!) film in the first place, but this was the nature of the Church then, and it still does this with Abortion and other events. It's a way to put their name on the front page! And your song, too!
 
Generally, for me, I do not go out and look for support or to be "published" or to get annointed as one of the club and a good writer. I think I'm OK, maybe better than average, but I lack the skills to make that decision, and evaluate things better all around. I do film/music reviews as a way to explain to myself, why I see things so differently, because discussing it with folks next to me, is a dead end ... always has been ... different languages!
 
All in all, it depends on what you want. But i am not sure that anyone can stop a piece that is very well written from not being heard and appreciated. But I am starting to think that too many of these "music" websites, are just more nobodies ... no one ever comes out of them ...
 
The best, for me so far? The Ygdrasil Journal of Poetic Arts ... like 25 years on, and I was there the first 10 years, and it is now catalogued in the Canada's National Library ... and we were so out there and open about poetry and what we did, that many folks, in alt.poetry and the like were intimidated by us ... because we were not topical ditties that meant nothing but a little fun!
 
I think that's the main difference!
2015/12/22 10:37:40
kakku
Tip from Mr. Dan Cumpian, do not send unfinished works and do not say they are unfinished. That is a , well, a sure way to not get comments if one starts telling about some unfinished job or if it sounds unfinished. Unless, as Dan says, you are stuck and asking for help.
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account