Maybe Robby wants every forum member (over .5M) to not only listen but comment?
 
That's Juan way to keep your song on page Juan.
 

I listen to almost everything that's posted on this forum, but for various reasons, I don't always comment...
One thing is for sure... If you do not comment on mine or others' music.., I will not comment on yours... unless you're a newby...
 
There are some here I admire very much, as players, and/or producers, but sadly, I guess my pride won't allow me to comment on their music, when experience shows they'll probably never reciprocate...     

Interesting thread.  I find that I 'listen' to songs in batches, like this morning, and I've commented on most that I heard, but I did not listen to all of them all the way through.  If I like the style or genre, I usually do listen to the whole song.  If I comment, I try to say something positive about the song, or the mix, or the musicianship.  On occasion I offer a suggestion, but as a relative newcomber and novice, I'm not really comfortable doing that or consider myself knowledgeable enough to. 
 
I think I can tell from the comments on my songs that some are essentially encouragement, 'Good so far', 'Keep going', while others are much more than that.  It never occurred to me that a poster didn't listen to 'any' of the song though.
 
 

This is kind of a bogus issue for me.  I'm always grateful if anyone responds to my posts.  I can tell the difference between chuff and the real advice that I'm seeking.  I guess that I don't take myself "seriously" enough.

notnat
There are some here I admire very much, as players, and/or producers

Since you do comment on songs I've been involved in, I must NOT be one of those.

bapu

notnat
There are some here I admire very much, as players, and/or producers

Since you do comment on songs I've been involved in, I must NOT be one of those.

No, you are not one of those...
I admire you as a player and producer and CH mob boss... and I like you... in spite of your singing...  

I would much rather see "good job", or "nice tune", or "keep going", as opposed to someone posting 2 paragraphs about their life in a post that I was truly looking for some meaningful feedback on. My 2 cents.

notnat

bapu

notnat
There are some here I admire very much, as players, and/or producers

Since you do comment on songs I've been involved in, I must NOT be one of those.

No, you are not one of those...
I admire you as a player and producer and CH mob boss... and I like you... in spite of your singing...  

Who says I can sing?

Good Job Robbaaay.......

Even when people comment within 2 minutes of posting it does not mean they did not listen.  Considering how common things like posting while at work is, it would n ot surprise me if people sometimes commented at a different time then when they actually listened.