Well, my visit in other forum did not last long either it seems. I put up one song up which I felt had a nice chorus, but indstead of saying the chorus wasn,'t bad or something positive, the feedback was only negative unlike here where the community is nice. Also I was expecting lots more comments. I got about 5.I don't say the forum name in case it is some rule.

People tend to be mean (unless you're praising them) so I usually avoid dealing with them.  My roommate's dog thinks I'm great so I usually ask his opinion about my efforts instead. 

As far as I can see Antti, this is quite a rare little corner of the internet. You will get a lot of back-slapping of course, but also constructive crits from experienced people. Mind you, I've never really investigated other DAW software forums except Presonus. Their version of the songs forum seemed very slow and poorly attended.

You are probably correct. One guy I accused of nastiness is an editor of the magazine that runs the forums, who also mentioned negative things but liked the flute sound. LoL. The song I put up was The Zoo. I knew it had flaws, but the chorus was OK in my books, although there could have been more variation like I admitted. The other guy had an elf avatar and used hth acronym in the ending which is sarcastic so I presume it is used to hurt people. First I accepted quietly the nastiness but when I found out what hth meant I got a bit berserk and charged with style imo. I told them that all are not so gifted and some respect should be given to less gifted people and so.

I just found out that my post failed probably because of the stupid time limit. So I have write again which is not nice becausen I am using a phone.

jamesg1213
As far as I can see Antti, this is quite a rare little corner of the internet. You will get a lot of back-slapping of course, but also constructive crits from experienced people. Mind you, I've never really investigated other DAW software forums except Presonus. Their version of the songs forum seemed very slow and poorly attended.

Thank you James. Still I feel important to answer to these guys. Kicks I get will young padawan.

kakku
will young

 
Oh come on, no need to bring HIM into it....

Go ahead Kakku....show em what you got!!
 

I don't know what you are complaining about Kakku. I went to the songs forum and you seem to be getting lots of positive comments, but you insist that people are slagging you. I don't understand.

ampfixer
I don't know what you are complaining about Kakku. I went to the songs forum and you seem to be getting lots of positive comments, but you insist that people are slagging you. I don't understand.

John he's not talking about the Cakewalk Songs forum.  he's talking about some other songs forum.

Beagle

ampfixer
I don't know what you are complaining about Kakku. I went to the songs forum and you seem to be getting lots of positive comments, but you insist that people are slagging you. I don't understand.

John he's not talking about the Cakewalk Songs forum.  he's talking about some other songs forum.

True and I don'tknowiif it is allowed to speakaboutother forums