On a sidetone - Even though in itself, the experience of listening to a vinyl record can be gratifying on many levels, the pragmatic in me sides with digital media.
That being said, I think that, no matter how hard they try and package them, CD's - as a physical support - suck. Not only do they have no personality, but from unwrapping to trying to remove the actual CD from it's jewel case w/o breaking anything, working with CDs seem to be an exercise in inconvenience.
The gratifying aspect of unpacking a vinyl, the smell of it, the static when you pulled the actual disc from its paper sleeve... If CD's offered anything similar in terms of experience, I might no be so prone to rip and store them.