2015/10/30 10:03:51
Moshkito
joakes
...
Sorry to disagree, but In the Air is one of the most horrible vocal styles i've ever heard. His voice just grates. And he keeps bringing it out.

No Son of Mine and some of its predessessors is molto better, but there's always that vocal style you either like or don't ! I don't.
....


I know, but goodness ... that would make Joe Cocker, Roger Chapman, Rod Stewart, the guy from Acqua Fragile/PFM and so many others not good singers and that is not the case. I don't think of this as a "vocal style" as much as I do, that the person is able to adjust his words to sing with it, and it's hard to say that Chappo is a bad singer when you hear "Gypsy Moon" and so other things. I am not sure it is a style ... I think it's more like ... that's the way it is pal ... this is the voice I got ...
2015/10/30 10:26:10
craigb
Personally, I like his voice - oh well.  Then again, I also like Richard Butler from the Psychedelic Furs too.
2015/10/30 10:48:15
Moshkito
craigb
Personally, I like his voice - oh well.  Then again, I also like Richard Butler from the Psychedelic Furs too.



Thank you! And that accent ... goodness!
2015/10/30 12:16:52
sharke
Personally I like his voice. It's distinctive. There are so many popular artists around these days with almost exactly the same voice, what I would call the "American Idol" sound. I hear so many young vocalists who sound identical right now, it's spooky. They all adopt the exact same vocal inflections and timbre, even a lot of the so-called "serious" artists who write and play their own music. I rarely hear anyone whose voice stands out as different. You hear people say things like "what a set of lungs on that girl," "he can really hold a note" or "what soul!" (which is just another way of saying they close their eyes when they sing and warble a scale run around every note) but never "he sounds like nobody else."

Weird or distinctive voices grow on you as an acquired taste. So much of today's music is sugary sweet and designed to have instant appeal but it's ultimately disposable.
2015/10/30 12:22:24
BobF
I really like the Phil tune about night air ...
2015/10/30 16:13:39
Moshkito
sharke
Personally I like his voice. It's distinctive. There are so many popular artists around these days with almost exactly the same voice, what I would call the "American Idol" sound. I hear so many young vocalists who sound identical right now, it's spooky. They all adopt the exact same vocal inflections and timbre, even a lot of the so-called "serious" artists who write and play their own music. I rarely hear anyone whose voice stands out as different. You hear people say things like "what a set of lungs on that girl," "he can really hold a note" or "what soul!" (which is just another way of saying they close their eyes when they sing and warble a scale run around every note) but never "he sounds like nobody else."
...

I've always thought that three folks that should spend time coaching kids at American Idol ... should be Bob Dylan (would teach them to use swear words!), Peter Hammill (would teach them to sing until there is no breath or song left!) and Roy Harper (keep on word'ing until the song is over, but the words aren't!) ... then we might have a nice competition!
2015/10/30 19:10:21
Beagle
jamesg1213
I think Phil's had enough bashing for now. Saw a very candid interview with him recently where he admitted that he'd overdone things and had way too much exposure in the '80's, especially the 'cheeky chappie' routine on stage. He said he could understand now why he would get on some people's nerves.
 
Sad about his health problems too, he looks a shadow of his former self these days.
 
Anyone heard his son Simon's stuff? Spooky...
 



I had not heard his stuff before, thanks for sharing!  he is definitely Phil's son...voice, looks even his hand motions and body language are distinctly "Phil-ish"


2015/10/30 20:18:50
Doktor Avalanche

 
 
He never retired just put a wig on.
 
 
 
'I can't dance' .. If ever there was a non musical song, done badly in a non sensicle way, this is it. Producing zero enjoyment.
2015/10/31 00:40:50
yorolpal
Even in this video and song Phil shows an engaging self deprecation. Perhaps nothing more than smart marketing...but still nothing that begs for the kind of derision he seems to attract.

Plus...you, your ownself, butchered the spelling and usage of nonsensical...which makes you sort of nonsensical yourself;-)
2015/10/31 01:15:27
Rain
I'm okay w/ I Can't Dance. Maybe not as a Genesis song, but, ok.
I've heard a lot worst a gazillion time.
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account