Hi Donny,
I liked the first mix and the second even better. I don't think there is any harm in adding some effect here and there...see what happens when you post a song? You might get two different opinions- Oh well! ;) I wouldn't make it wet but a little verb in the right places would be nice IMO.Maybe even a slight delay in the drums.
The one predominant thing I noticed and I'm surprised no one else mentioned is that snare hit. To me it sounds a little too forward, almost to the point of commanding the whole mix. I would lay it back a little in the mix, maybe even eq it another place to make it a little less aggressive.
You are a really talented guy. The vocals are excellent. The song tends to give a relaxed feeling. It was a pleasant listen.