Hi John, I hear what you are saying but here is the rub and is the crux of your argument. I've tried to get other projects over the line including analysing and recreating Beatle tracks...good for those who really want to learn about the art of production. Improvisation using nothing more than the iphone/ipad combination still no go but this is what the academics want, or so I've been lead to believe and again I might be leading myself up the garden path on this one.
As for what I am trying to achieve with this project, well at the moment I'm still working this one out but after two attempts I am starting to figure this out. Basically what I have done is recreate the sound map of the area I recorded and turned it into music. Ok huh? if you strip away the melody that I have imposed on top of the rhythm track you actually here the sounds of the street or the sound map. Now what I have done is then gone this is how this area makes me feel. So it's a street, the noises that you hear on this street are very repetitive, so hence the repetitive nature of the rhythm track. The voices that you hear also are super important because they give the piece a narrative, the area it's self is one of disadvantage, if you listen carefully there is an indigenous person talking about her son and alcohol. The area is also very dirty and grimy. So what I have done is ok lets turn the sounds into a blue's sort of piece to represent the sounds and the area. This is my interpretation of the area, my feelings about the area I live in.
It is weird, it's not "music" but it is art is music is noise, LoL. Don't forget these experiments have been going on now for over a 100 years, starting with the futurists in 1909 and are basically a rebelling or was a rebellion at the time against the neo classical movement of the time. And again this sort of project is an attempt at rebellion too, music is pretty staid and boring, possibly not to you but def for me. So this my attempt to re-write the wheel, so to speak.
And finally this is only my 2nd attempt at doing this and so far I have chosen rather dark grim subjects to paint but imagine what a park or a garden might sound like? How do I represent a butterfly flying through the air on a summers day with only the sounds I have gathered in that park.
So give me time to figure this stuff out, at the moment you are asking van gogh to paint sunflowers and he's only just been given his yellow paint.
Peace Ben