I try and appreciate the music for what it is and not take the drama into account. As such, Van Halen has quite a bunch of terrific albums - almost everything up to Unlawful is top notch rock and roll.
In terms of singing, there's no doubt in my mind that Hagar is a much better singer - whereas Roth has an incredible tone and is a great performer - though at times, too much of a clown for my own taste.
As for personal drama, considering how EVH publicly dismissed Randy Rhoads and allegedly behaved like a complete arse when Rhoads tried to talk technique with him, his outrageous comments about Michael Anthony don't really impress me. He made a fool of himself, really.
I'm pretty sure young Randy was thinking of Eddie when he said:
For someone like Randy, who actually taught guitar, who was always eager to learn and to exchange, EVH's attitude made no sense.