Are we talking the FIRST IM album or the first one with Bruce (NOTB)?
I actually love the sound of NOTB even though it's definitely "lo fi" by today's standards. It's very warm, human and real. You can hear everything in balance and it sounds like a "band" not a bunch of disparate sounds mixed together and maximized.
TBH the stuff they did after that, although musically great, turns me off because of the sheer crispness/perfection of the production. Those albums sound like the studio... not the band. HOWEVER those albums also have a production quality I FAR prefer to almost everything else coming out of studios at the time. For example you can actually hear the damned bass (a rarity in that era of metal albums) and all the instruments are nice and full (whereas other albums were kind of thin and mosquitoey).
The REALLY early stuff (pre NOTB) though should really be taken for what they are. Demo's of a unique band performing a unique new style of music (and that band in particular were even unique within that new genre). I don't think even the top producers really would have known what to do with something like that at the time.
Also back then they were a LOT sloppier than they became (but still really good comparitively).
I do like those albums for sure and I'm probably an outlier as far as my ears/taste in metal sounds but they are pretty low rent. As a massive fan of early punk though that rawness certainly is part of the charm for me.
Now a CRAPPY sounding album, to me, is Metallica's Kill 'em All. Horrible sounding record but I still like it. Their production values after that (up to and even including And Justice which would be my FAVORITE Metallica record if not for the lack of bass... Newstead got a raw deal on that) were right up my alley. Warm, full and tight without losing that "band" feel. Black album and beyond... sounds like the studio. Blech... (and I won't even go into my thoughts on the music itself).
But as I said I like punk and actually most of my favorite recordings are well produced live performances.
I just like to listen to bands, warts and all, over "albums".
Meh... without reading the interview I can't form an opinion on what he said. I like Bruce but he is a bit pompous at times. He is however highly intelligent, educated and accomplished so in some ways I guess he can get away with a bit of that.
Still doesn't negate the fact he kind of sings like Ethel Merman... which still makes me snicker as I listen to them ever since someone pointed that out to me. lulz