• Songs
  • "Carry Me" - Acoustic Ballad - Mix 3 - 6-21-13 (p.4)
2013/06/01 20:07:53
markno999
Bob,
 
Good song and performance, very catchy.   I agree you could add a nice power ballad guitar solo if you decide to go that direction.   If I had one nit it would be the pad, I find the pad very distracting from the acoustic guitars and the vocals.    I think the song stands without the pad, or, you could add some strings in certain parts for decoration.  Just my opine...   But really nice work.
 
Regards
2013/06/01 20:12:42
timidi
This isn't one of my favorites of your's Bob. Kind of monotonous. It's well done and sounds great.
2013/06/14 04:13:33
Bob Oister
NOTE:  New Mix Up 6-14-13 - As per your input and suggestions, I edited/removed the distracting vocal breaths, re-eqed bass for more definition and adjusted the bass volume level, and added a few light drum fills to help differentiate the song sections.  Thanks so much for all your great input, observations and ideas!
 
Once again, very sorry for the late replies, been super busy at work and haven't had much time to jump on here!  WOW!  We've even got nice looking new forum software since I was on last!  I promise to try to catch up on some listening very soon!
 
 
notnat:
 
 
Hi Frank,
 
Thanks very much, buddy, I really appreciate you checking it out and also your kind words!  I'm still debating about adding a short acoustic bridge or possibly an electric solo, although I'm really not sure about making it much longer than the 3:29 that it already is.  Who knows?
 
I greatly appreciate your input, Frank, and have a good one!
Bob
====================================
 
 
 
 
The Rebel:
 
 
Hey, Dan,
 
Thanks so much, brother, you made my day!   I really appreciate you checking this one out for me, and also giving a listen to my usual rock and metal stuff!
 
By the way, really nice work on your recent, very cool cover version of "Come Together", excellent job on that!
 
Thanks again, Dan, I'm truly grateful for your input and kind words, greatly appreciated.  Have a rockin' weekend!
Bob
=====================================
 
 
 
 
drumstixkev:
 
 
Hey, Kev,
 
How's it going, buddy?  Hope you're doing great!
 
Big thanks for giving this one a listen, and also for your kind words and good input!
 
LOL, yeah, I originally thought I could get away with the breaths in the choruses because of the intimate acoustic environment, but I knew when I posted it that it already distracted me while I was doing the mix.  I'm actually really glad that you mentioned it to confirm that I should have gone with my original feelings.  For this new mix, I track edited the vocals to remove the breaths.  I'm always afraid of making things sound too sterile, but I sure don't want to end up with a situation like Steve Miller's "Big Old Jet Airliner".  I remember thinking how those deep breaths on that song always stuck out like a sore thumb ever since I won the album at a Wildwood New Jersey Boardwalk game booth on a vinyl LP way back when it was first released.  LOL, That song sounded like an obscene phone call!
 
Thanks again, Kev, I always look forward to and appreciate your good input and support on my stuff. 
 
Have a great night, Kev!
Bob
===================================
 
 
 
 
Serious_Noise!:
 
 
Hey, Bobby,
 
Thanks, buddy, I really appreciate you checking the song out and your very encouraging comments!
 
Nope, I never had any type of vocal lessons, I'm completely self taught, but I've been singing lead and background vocals in a gazillion different cover bands since I was thirteen years old.  I was only playing guitar for about two and a half months when I got conned into trying to sing.  LOL, I can still remember the sheer terror as I stepped up to the microphone for the very first time in my first garage band, to try to croak out the lead vocals for Grand Funk Railroad's "I'm Your Captain (Closer To Home)".  I remember sweating and really thinking that I sounded crappy, but then the other guys in the band started nodding their heads and smiling so, it encouraged me to keep going all the way through the entire ten minute song!  YIKES!  So I ended up being the band's singer after that.
 
Anyway, thanks again, Bobby, for giving this a listen and for bringing back some memories of the good old days for me! Have a rockin' weekend, buddy!
Bob
=====================================
 
 
 
 
 
rsp-odysseynet:
 
 
Hey, Randy, how are you, my friend?  Hope you're doing great!
 
Thank you so much for taking time to check this one out for me, and for your very good ideas and kind words!
 
I tried to break up the sections a bit on the new mix with a few very simple drum fills, hopefully to differentiate the verses and choruses a little better.
 
I truly appreciate you giving this a listen and also your great input and suggestions, especially because your stuff always sounds so good! 
 
Have a great weekend, Randy!
Bob
=====================================
 
 
 
 
Guitarpima:
 
 
Hey, Robert,
 
How's it going, brother?  Hope you're doing great!
 
Big thanks for giving this a listen and your very encouraging comments!  I'm very grateful for your input and appreciate your friendship and support here on the forum. 
 
Have a good one, buddy!
Bob
=====================================
 
 
 
 
eric paul:
 
 
 
Hey, Eric,
 
How are you my friend?  It's really great to see you back around on the forum, hope you're doing well!
 
Thank you so much for checking this song out for me, and for your very kind words!
 
I really appreciate your input and your comments. 
 
Best wishes for a great weekend!
Bob
======================================
 
 
 
 
SteveStrummerUK:
 
 
 
Hey, Steve,
 
How's my good buddy from across the pond doing?  I hope you're giving good old "Ruby" a nice workout with your new amp!
 
Thanks very much for giving this a listen and your kind words of encouragement!  LOL, I had to physically restrain myself from going all "Hellion" and "Electric Eye" with my Les Paul in the middle of this one!  Well, I guess it's good to "mellow out" once in a while anyway!
 
Thanks again, Steve, for all of your good input, friendship and support here on the forum.  It really means a lot to me! 
 
Have a great weekend, brother!
Bob
====================================
 
2013/06/14 10:54:25
THE NIGHT FOX
Hi again Bob , this mix really sounds great ! Everything sits right in the mix , a nice balance going on here .
 
Nice work -James
2013/06/14 11:12:08
Wookiee
As I said previously a pleasure to hear you do something like this and as James observes the mix is pretty much spot on.  
 
If I was to offer a minor crit there is an element of monotony with your drummer, for me he sounds lifeless.  But of course that could just be my furry ears.
 
Thanks again for sharing your talents
2013/06/21 04:55:02
Bob Oister
NOTE: Mix #3 up 6/21/13.  Added a few small piano fills and re-eqed things a little bit.
 
 
Philip:
 
 
Hi, Philip,
 
How are you, my friend?  Hope you're doing great!
 
A sincere, whole-hearted thank-you for giving this song a listen, and for your very kind words and encouraging comments!
 
I greatly appreciate you taking time to always check out my song posts, and also your helpful input, comments and suggestions.  Your productions are always top notch, and your friendship and support here on the forum truly means a lot to me.
 
Best wishes for a wonderful weekend, Philip!
Bob
===================================
 
 
chasmcg:
 
 
Hey, Charlie,
 
Thanks so much, buddy, I really appreciate you checking this one out for me, and also your very kind words!
 
I'm very grateful for your input, especially because your stuff always sounds fantastic.
 
Thanks again, Charlie, and have a great weekend!
Bob
===================================
 
 
 
Wookiee:
 
 
Hey, Wook,
 
How are you, brother?  Hope you're doing great, it's always a pleasure to hear from you!
 
Thank you very much for giving this a listen, and for your good input and encouraging words!  I'm hoping the newly added drum fills and little piano fills break up the sections a bit more, and hopefully alleviate some of the repetitiousness.
 
Because it started out as just a gear test, and with only acoustic guitar and vocals, when I decided to add the drums, bass, strings and piano, I tried to simplify the drums a bit more like a country style drummer would play, as opposed to my normal clumsy, hard rock drum bashing.  LOL, YIKES!  That wouldn't be good!
 
Thanks again for your input, I always look forward to and greatly appreciate your input, comments and ideas!
 
Best wishes for a great weekend!
Bob
====================================
 
 
Lynn:
 
 
Hey, Lynn,
 
How are you, buddy?  Hope you're gearing up for a rockin' weekend!
 
Thank-you so much for checking this one out for me, and for your very encouraging comments and observations!  And, also for the kind words about my music website, I greatly appreciate it.
 
I'm very grateful for your good input, friendship and support, especially because of the high quality of the productions that you post here on the forum.
 
Thanks again, Lynn, and have a good one, my friend!
Bob
=====================================
 
 
 
Theycallmefree:
 
 
Hey, Free,
 
Thank you, Sir, I really appreciate you taking time to give this song a listen and also your very kind words!
 
I'll definitely have to check into Ursa Major online, because in the early days I learned some of my guitar style from the first couple Alice Cooper albums during the Glen Buxton years, namely "Love It To Death" and "Killer".  After a quick search I just realized that Dick Wagner played with Lou Reed on the live album, and one of my cover bands used to start the night with the long dual guitar intro and "Sweet Jane" from that record.  I also never knew that he was the guitar player on the "Welcome To My Nightmare" album.  I'll be checking out Ursa Major for sure!
 
Thanks again for your input, observations and comments.  Greatly appreciated, my friend, have a super weekend!
Bob
======================================
 
2013/06/21 10:14:16
THE NIGHT FOX
Sounds really good Bob , I like the MIX now . Not sure if I ask you but are you using a AMP or AMP simulator in your PC like I'm using ?
I can't get that sound your getting , maybe I'm not mixing my guitar track correctly of something hell I don't know but whatever your doing sure sounds great !
 
James
 
 
2013/06/26 03:12:09
Bob Oister
foxwolfen:
 
 
Hi, Shad,
 
How are you, brother?  Hope you're doing well!
 
Thank you very much for giving this a listen, and for your very kind words!
 
I always appreciate your good input and observations, and I'm very grateful for all your support here on the forum.
 
Have a good one, my friend!
Bob
====================================
 
 
 
CLEAN:
 
 
Hey, Mark,
 
How are you, buddy?  Hope you're doing great!
 
Thanks so much for checking this song out for me, and for the wonderful compliment!
 
I greatly appreciate your words of encouragement, and I'm only getting better at learning this recording and mixing stuff due to the great input and observations from you and the other very helpful members of this forum.  That generous input and advice from the crew here is what makes this such a great place! 
 
Thanks again, Mark, have a great day!
Bob
=====================================
 
 
 
Starise:
 
 
Hey, Tim,
 
How's my fellow Pennsylvania musician doing?  Hope you're doing great!
 
Thank you for giving "Carry Me" a listen and for your very kind words! Yes, Sir, you have very good ears, the left side acoustic is a six string, and the right side is a twelve string, so you were spot on! 
 
I'm very grateful that you like the song, and truly appreciate your very good input, and your support here on the forum.
 
Have a good one, Tim!
Bob
====================================
 
 
 
markno999:
 
 
Hey, Mark,
 
How are you, buddy?  Hope you're having a rockin' week!
 
Thank you so much for lending your good ears to this one for me, and for your good input and kind words of encouragement!
 
For the latest mix, I added a few little piano fills in certain spots and made some minor adjustments to the strings, I'm hoping it sounds a bit better at this point.
 
Thanks again for your friendship and support , greatly appreciated, buddy! 
Bob
=====================================
 
 
 
timidi:
 
 
Hey, Tim,
 
How's it going, buddy?  Hope you're doing well!
 
Thanks for checking in on this one for me, and for your input and kind words!
 
The song is really just an accident that happened when I wanted to test out  a new mic preamp, and opened up a blank Sonar project with absolutely no idea what I was going to sing or play to test the preamp settings.  Bang, the opening chords and vocal melody/lyrics just popped into my brain like a lightning strike, and after checking the playback of the acoustic and solo vocal, I decided to flesh it out into a full song.  So, it is what it is, I guess! 
 
Thanks again, Tim for always giving my stuff a listen and your input and observations!
Bob
===================================
 
 
 
THE NIGHT FOX:
 
Hey, James,
 
How's it going, buddy?  Hope you're doing great!
 
Thanks so much for coming back for a second listen and for your very kind words!  Greatly appreciated, my friend, and I'm very happy that you like the song! 
 
Have a great day, James!
Bob
===================================
 
 
 
Wookiee:
 
 
Hey, Wook,
 
How's it going, my friend?  Hope you're having a rockin' week!
 
Thank you very much for checking back in a second time on this one, and for your encouraging words and good input!
 
Yes, Sir, I wasn't quite sure on how to approach the drums on this because I thought it would be acoustic guitar and vocals only.  As I mentioned above, I decided to just try a very basic country style drum feel, as opposed to a rock style with lots of flourishes and over the top fills, to just keep it simple.  Although, I did add a few very light drum fills to try to break up the sections a bit more.
 
Thanks again, John, I truly appreciate your input, friendship and support! 
 
Best wishes!
Bob
======================================
 
 
 
THE NIGHT FOX:
 
 
 
Hey, James,
 
Thanks for coming back to check out Mix #3 of "Carry Me", and for your very nice comments and observations!
 
Yes, Sir, I use Line 6 POD Farm 2.5 to record all my bass, electric and acoustic guitars.  Keep plugging away, James, you're doing really well at learning the guitar and how to tastefully add it to your great sounding electronica songs.  You're music and mixing is getting better every time you post a new song, so keep up the good work! 
 
Thanks again for always checking out my song posts, and for your friendship and support, buddy!
 
Have a great day!
Bob
===================================
2013/07/19 11:36:29
theguitarplayer
Yes, Yes, Yes!!! This was just awesome all the way around. Had to give you Five Big Stars for this one and it was well deserving of 10, but they only allow 5. Very, very nice song. Make my day complete. Nice one.
 
Peace and Blessings, John
2013/07/19 11:52:44
Wookiee
Now I understand your vision for the drummer I can understand the understated style.
 
Very enjoyable song Sir Bob, nicely played with good presentation and excellent mix, thanks for sharing.
 

© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account