Base 57
When clips appear grey, it is usually because the track edit filter is set to something other than "clips".
Here's an update because it turns out your answer may not be the solution (but I'm leaving the door open that I've missed something

).
I set up a folder, added the track for the clean input, created the patch point, and then created three new tracks with the patch point at the input, each of the 3 with a different amp simulation plugin. I then recorded the clean signal ONLY on the 3 plugin tracks, and when finished a proper waveform was there (in color). I can edit it, etc.
Control+Z to go back and then armed the clean input track along with the 3 plugins, and during recording colored waveform showed, but when I finished all were grey. And "clips" was the focus of all four Filter buttons. Odd.
Again, there may well be a logical reason for this but darned if I can figure it out.