Westside Steve Simmons
Thanks for the info. I guess the convenience of switching sounds in a software plug makes a lot of sense. Do any of the plugs come with a plethora of presets and are any suitable for an acoustic guutar input as well?
WSS
POD HD is the most viable cheap option on the used market in my experience. The presets are garbage, so you need to know how to set things up. However, it does have a computer GUI if you connect via usb which makes programming sounds easy.
You can remove the amp sims and use an acoustic guitar, though recording guitar via a pickup is quite frankly a disaster in and of itself. Guitar pickups just don't sound great.
I strongly prefer playing guitar through hardware into an interface.
Guitar players (myself included) tend to prefer switching between sounds with ones feet while they play. Doing it in "post" from a plugin is terrible on so many levels.
Are you looking for a solution for yourself or other guitar players (clients)? If you are the guitar player what is your experience level?
Amp with Mic is the real way to do it, but that is not practical for a lot of people. The really good products like the Kemper, AxeFX, Helix are not exactly cheap, and I'm implying from your initial post that you likely are not in the professional guitarist realm that these tools are really aimed at.