I understand the students reaction - mine was the same! I mean - we only have one sentence, so we don't know what the father did to his daughter - but no, we DO know. at first, when the sentence builds up, slowly, compaigned by noise sounding like hits from a belt, it really makes you shiver. then, the sentence disappears, again slowly, with the sad piano to it, and it feels like the woman is vanishing away. her personality, her love for life is vanishing away, killed by what the father did to her. this is a fascinating concept on a dark subject. my highest respect for this!