Thanks Ed, and yes, I agree. It's really just two different sides of the same coin. Thanks for letting me help flip it! (I'm a fan of tails myself... Butt who didn't see THAT coming!?) :-)

Total sweetness all around.

Chicken to the bone Robby.
Very well done!!!!!
 
 

notnat


Wow... that is very good Robby... Love the Harmony & Background vocals... Nice...

Thanks Frank, it means a lot coming from you as you are someone I really look up to.

ohgrant


 Love the harmonies, main vocal melody much clearer. Much better, great job. Really great lyrics, if I didn't know any better I would say ED is a country boy.

Thanks Grant :-) I like the harmonies too :-) Like I said, it's just a flip side of the same coin. I like all 3, Gary's original, Ed's version, and mine. Great song, thank you for listening and for commenting. 

I think it was Ed who said something like Robby could sing the phone book and make it sound good , so give the man two cracks at a a classy, well produced ballad and he's just gonna' shine.  I've heard both, and I really like both.  Good listening all the way.

Right on. I like this. Much prefer the vocal styling here (the other one was sterile IMO). The slide guitar set my teeth on edge much like fingernails on a blackboard, but slide guitars do that to me regardless of who is playing it. I do like the equal voicing between it and you though.

foxwolfen


Right on. I like this. Much prefer the vocal styling here (the other one was sterile IMO). The slide guitar set my teeth on edge much like fingernails on a blackboard, but slide guitars do that to me regardless of who is playing it. I do like the equal voicing between it and you though.

Have you heard the re-tracked vocals on the other from two days ago, yet?

And again, this is not a competition. I agree the first take on the other version was sterile as Robby was not quite into what I was wanting and I had to do serious edits to get it closer to my "vision". His re-tracked vocals are right on as well as being stellar here too.

They're both  Great? Listen to both? :-) Bapu is a great producer? I like my stuff too?

My version is my take on it? It's a little different? But hey? We're all producers...

Ed is a great producer!

It's just different sides of the same Fraking coin!!

I have not listened to the other new mix yet, no. Please make no mistake. I was not talking about Ed's production skills here. It is about Robby's flow as a vocalist.