It's all good :-) I love Ed, and he love me :-)

Thanks buddy.

Well.. I may love Ed more in a "1st night in prison?" kind of way? But that doesn't mean I don't still love him?  

I really feel for him? ED! OVER HERE!  

I'm sorry for that right there Lord.

Well, I listened to both back to back (flipped between them to hear certain parts) and, sadly, the mix is part of the problem on Eds song. However, there were a couple of moments on Eds song, when you fihished a phrase near the middle that had much more impact than the same moment in your mix. I will try to nail it down if you wish.

Well, as much as I appreciate your ears? And believe me I do? And I do? 

I don't want to get in to a here vs. There? 

But that doesn't mean I "and we?" don't appreciate your input? We appreciate it VERY MUCH!! Thank you so much for listing and for commenting. 

The Band19


Well, as much as I appreciate your ears? And believe me I do? And I do? 

I don't want to get in to a here vs. There? 

But that doesn't mean I "and we?" don't appreciate your input? We appreciate it VERY MUCH!! Thank you so much for listing and for commenting. 

+1

Hi Robby,

Another awesome job on the lead and harmony vocals, arrangement, production, etc, etc... 

I'm not gonna get dragged into a 'which version is better' argument because I'm pretty sure it's not a competition...I could be wrong, though 

Please bear in mind that the two versions are NOT a competition. 
Ed 2-9-2013

Again, as Ed said, "It is NOT a competition!"
Robby 2-11-2013


As I said in my Coffee House Collaborators "We Drift Apart" thread, this was not a competition
Ed 2-17-2013


And again, this is not a competition
Ed 2-19-2013

Excellent work by both you and Ed! Even if it's NOT a competition.

It's been hard for me to get passed Gary's excellent song/production as It's engrained in my brain.

All these attempts to add words and altered melodies seems to fall short to me.

But Robbaaay, You did sing the **** out of this here.. Great vocs...

geeare1


Hi Robby,

Another awesome job on the lead and harmony vocals, arrangement, production, etc, etc... 

I'm not gonna get dragged into a 'which version is better' argument because I'm pretty sure it's not a competition...I could be wrong, though 

Please bear in mind that the two versions are NOT a competition. 
Ed 2-9-2013

Again, as Ed said, "It is NOT a competition!"
Robby 2-11-2013


As I said in my Coffee House Collaborators "We Drift Apart" thread, this was not a competition
Ed 2-17-2013


And again, this is not a competition
Ed 2-19-2013

Excellent work by both you and Ed! Even if it's NOT a competition.

LMAO!!!!!!

defenetly not my music but it sounds very pro Cheers :-)

Lovely song, beautifully sung. Everything sounds great, I hear more vintage country than Eagles though. In a good way.

It is not about competition. It is about arriving at the best possible song, and I believe that can be accomplished with a little give and take. Each track has its merits and each track has its weaknesses. But I think if you can find the middle ground, you will have a song that will be memorable (and saleable - yes I am a capitalist... sue me ).