alewgro
plus there are VERY heavy bass albums released on Vinyl today - I've heard them on Vinyl... they are BASS HEAVY!
Yes yes. But bass is not the only thing in a recording. It's been answered a few times already: You can't have all of it on vinyl (normal 33 rpm): Clarity/separation from bottom to the highs, loud enough but with dynamics, and bassy. So the bass heavy vinyls you hear have sacrificed something to make that bassyness possible.
There were special editions of vinyls (I think it's called "direct carving" or something) used especially for classical music. They had a better dynamic separation and a warning on the cover that they may break your loudspeakers.
Also they were manufactured of somehow better vinyl, and they were very expensive.
Then were (and still are today, I assume), as mentioned, so called maxi-singles, which are the same size as LP's, but were played 45 rpm. They had better sound as well.
I do think that two of the reasons, in addition to the requirements of different genres, were:
- People were not used to overly bassy sounds. Very many thought that reggae sounded stupid.
- In the 60's and 70's especially young people had often very modest sound reproduction systems.
It was useless to make records with deep basses for loudspeakers that couldn't go below 60 Hz and did not have any compensating EQ circuits to protect the loudspeakers.
I remember once listening Tubular Bells through loudspeakers that went "brrrrrrrrrrrrr" every time the low organ sounds came to picture.