I listened over the weekend but wanted to let it stew in me for a while before listening again to confirm what I felt the first time.
I loved the intro so much. I like the chorus quite a bit.
But two things are bugging me:
The snare drum is waaaay too snappy and punchy that it distracts and seems out of place with the rest of the instruments.
Robby's almost-instantaneous vibrato from the get-go on the first verse really made things seem old-fashioned, like Englebert-old fashioned, so not retro, but cornball. He's a much better singer with better sensibilities than that.