"but, I would think your "fans" want to hear you sing... "


Sing over an instrumental tune? Hummmm, now there's an idea! Brilliant!!

The Band19


"but, I would think your "fans" want to hear you sing... "


Sing over an instrumental tune? Hummmm, now there's an idea! Brilliant!!

Not according to Tim.

Errr.. no... not sing over an instrument track... Robby, you did read Tim's post right? He said "if you have no other instrumental tracks, yes". I think he was saying he prefers a track with Frank singing over this one. I am replying for him mostly to show that what he said did in fact make sense. When read correctly. - edit - just saw the post by Tim on Robby and Ed's song. Now I understand.

I think Phil makes a valid point.

I think Scotty makes a valid point, and I think I made a valid pint. And BAPU's points are always valued. "Some" of Mooch's points are not valid. Most of Freddy's are? Most of TIMI's are. There are others who make valid posts too. I hope this post is valid. It's after midnight here, please take that in to consideration. Still though? I believe I made valid points.

I think Beyonce had some valid points at the superbowl half time... I really enjoyed her points (they were valid.)

Indeed. I think we all made valid points. I think I am also caught in a cross post lashback I should have foreseen, and will end any further part in it at this time.

A cross post lashback? I'm afraid religion is strictly forbidden? Discussion of crosses, and lashes and whatnot, is spelled out in some detail? I'm surprised you're not in the know on all of this Shad? You see, it seems we're supposed to refrain from controversy? And or "controversial issues?" It feels controversial to even bring it up? Although having my back "lashed" may not be all that bad under the right circumstances? 

WAIT!? Are we talking about the same thing? 

(Sorry Frank... many apologies.)


I'm sorry for that right there Lord... And please be with the Pygmies in New Guinea. 

I'm just in from our regular Tuesday night jam session, and I'm feeling like I've missed a party...

Thanks for all the comments everyone...

I am sensing some tension... and I think I know why... Ironically this music started off as a vocal tune I wrote for Imogen Heap, and was transformed into an instrumental, unlike another that evolved the other way around...

The sax is way too loud... really?

YOU'RE WORSE THAN HITLER!

For the record Frank, no tension here and I even sent a PM to Tim on his remark in my thread and hopefully he sees I was not offended.

Just wanted to clear that up.

It behooves us all to remember opinions are just that, opinions; and I for one try to only deal with the opinions on technical aspects of mix and (generally) let song structure/style opinions roll off my back.