• Songs
  • New original rock song (Lose that Tone) from my band Wallow Sound. Mix Crits welcome (p.2)
2013/01/11 11:17:09
Guitarhacker
Nice work there Chuck... I agree with the others on the low end... 

I also know what the band is saying and wanting... maybe that's why it's a good idea to have a disinterested third party mix/master the tracks. 

However....

With proper EQ and compression you can lose the "woof" and keep the punch and bottom end. That would satisfy the band I'm sure. 

Best of luck,... you got a good song there. 
2013/01/11 17:09:33
whack
Cool. .Listening on a lapper.

Love the very start (foo figthers type riff).

Vocals awesome and some great energy and grit there.

The squirelly lead guitar was a bit too prominent for me in places with the lead vocal.Cant comment much on the bass.

3:08, love that solo vocal breakdown :-), makes this song IMO and its what I remembered when it finished.

Cian
2013/01/11 18:19:01
philz
Really good tune and excellent performances.  I'd like to hear a bit more of the vocal, but that could be a taste thing.  Well done.
2013/01/11 21:05:37
dcumpian
Excellent tune and really nice energy! Nothing to add that hasn't already been said.

Regards,
Dan
2013/01/12 12:02:56
drumstixkev
Hey Chuck
This tune ROCKS!  Great work on the vox harmonies.  Mix sounds good on my end but could use a smidge more mid and low end depth. One of your best IMO.  KUDOS!


Kev
2013/01/12 12:22:38
Razorwit
Hi Chuck,
Wow...nice work. I don't know that I'd change much. Incidentally, are the drums a live mic'd kit or a sampled set?

Dean
2013/01/12 16:07:21
ChuckC
Daren- Thanks man, I assume the Limp bizkit your picking up there is the bass's tone and drum groove in the versus.  I don't really see it, but I'll take it!  Thanks man

Bit- Yeah the kick sound I had kind of rang there to start with and gave me the idea,  I then added an instance of Session drummer with just those kick hits & detuned it to get that sub low BOOM.  I am tweaking it now to give it some mids too, as I found that effect is inaudible on small systems like a laptop on this mix.  Thanks for the tip on the vocals.

James- Thank you sir.

Herb- Yeah it has been trying at times dealing with the guys.  I want to make it more sonic-ly correct?(if that makes sense) but I see their point too as most other music in this style is mixed for earbud listening.

Whack- yep on a laptop you don't hear as much of lows in his voice and the guitars get tangled in the upper end of his vocal.  The vocal break is fun, and has just enough cheese factor to get the crowd involved at the live shows.  haha  by the time we get to that 3rd pre-chorus they are singing along with it.

Philz-  Thanks bud, I am fixing that now.  I find I often get "done" then later have to bump my vocal tracks by about a half a Db almost all the time because I have heard it so many times that I mix it a hair low.

Dan - Thank you for your time and the kind words!

Kev-I am working on it.

Dean-Thank man, The drums on this were recorded midi with my Roland V kit and sent through EZ drummer.  Then I tweaked, eq'd and used some parallel compression techniques on them.  They will sound better/bigger in my revised mix.  P.S.  I love that you couldn't tell and had to ask!

2013/01/12 18:02:15
Razorwit
Hi Chuck,
That actually makes a ton of sense on the drums...from an audio perspective they sounded like they might have been sampled or had lots of heavy drum replacement/reinforcement done, but they playing sounds like a real live person. In any case, they sound fantastic.

Dean
2013/01/12 18:15:26
notnat
Nice work Chuck... Rhythm guitar intro is excellent... Lo-end issues, easy fix... this is fine work Chuck...
2013/01/13 14:40:58
ChuckC
Thanks nonat! That's me! =) I tightened up the lo end in my new mix by upping the Q on my HP filter on the bass guitar, and then tweaking the kick sound to let it thump a hair more without the masking effects between the two. I will be posting it shortly.
12
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account