• Coffee House
  • Sir David Attenborough - "BBC is all cookery and quizzes"
2014/10/16 14:03:18
SteveStrummerUK
 
 
Have to say I agree with a lot of what he says, although to fair to Auntie Beeb, there is some great lower budget factual programming hidden away on BBC4.
 
Full article from Mail Online:
=================================================================
 
Sir David Attenborough - BBC is all cookery and quizzes: Veteran broadcaster criticises lack of hard-hitting documentary series like Civilisation and Life On Earth
 
  • Sir David, 88, was controller of BBC Two in the 1960s and 1970s
  • There is now a shortage of highbrow programmes about science, natural history and music on BBC
  • Presenter has made a new BBC One natural history series called Life Story
  • Doesn't watch quiz shows because he has 'quite a lot to do' 
 
Sir David Attenborough has accused the BBC of making too many cookery programmes and quiz shows and not enough landmark documentaries.
 
He said the corporation’s decision-making is so slow it is no longer able to produce classic series such as Civilisation or Life on Earth.
 
Instead, our screens are dominated by quiz shows, drama series and cookery programmes such as the BBC’s The Great British Bake Off, all of which he refuses to watch.
 
The veteran wildlife presenter said he was able to make some of his greatest programmes because he had the freedom to pursue his ideas – and health and safety was treated as a ‘joke’.
 
But he suggested he would no longer be able to make them under the current stifling management culture. ‘The trouble is, the BBC falls over backwards with all kinds of committees and surveys to make sure that [the commissioning process] is as fair as it can possibly be, but the consequence is it moves at an elephantine pace,’ he told the Radio Times.
 
Sir David, 88, was controller of BBC Two in the 1960s and 1970s and commissioned some of the corporation’s best known series, such as Kenneth Clark’s Civilisation in 1969. The following decade, he made his own landmark documentary, Life on Earth, which also ran for 13 episodes.
 
But he said there is now a shortage of long-running highbrow programmes about subjects such as science, natural history and music on the BBC. ‘There are a great number of subjects that aren’t covered,’ he added.
 
Sir David accused station controllers of being obsessed by just a few genres that become ‘flavour of the month’.
 
The presenter, who has made a new BBC One natural history series called Life Story, added: ‘I don’t watch any cookery programmes, whether they are competitive, whether it’s the Great Bake Off, or… I don’t watch quizzes either. I mean, they’re perfectly OK – I’m not being snobbish about them – but I’ve quite a lot to do and I don’t put on the television as a sort of “filler”.’
 
His comments came after actor Charles Dance, 68, criticised British TV drama directors. ‘I don’t think enough risks are being taken in drama television in the UK and I think a lot of programme makers are underestimating the intelligence of the viewing public, basing it all on ratings,’ he told The Guardian.
 
A BBC spokesman said: ‘With current shows like Wonders of the Monsoon, and the forthcoming series Life Story, the BBC’s reputation for producing world-class natural history programming is as strong today as it’s ever been.’
 
 
 
 
 
 
2014/10/16 14:32:31
jamesg1213
As much as I like and admire Sir David, I'm not sure I agree with him. He appears to be ignoring the entire content of BBC4, which has pretty much everything he thinks is missing. Charles Dance says there's a lack of 'taking risks' in drama - I wonder if he saw the recent series 'Happy Valley' which was one of the most hard-hitting and nail-biting pieces of drama I've seen in many years.
2014/10/16 15:14:51
sharke
I haven't lived in the UK for almost 12 years and I have to say the BBC had a bit of a cheap junk feel to it even back then.

Having said that, this is the direction all TV has taken - it's not just the Beeb. TV stations have realized that that cookery shows, DIY shows, quizzes, talent shows and trash-talking reality shows are relatively cheap to make and the lowest common denominator LOVE them. Which is why I got rid of my set 10 years ago and these days just watch the odd choice show on Netflix.

I was watching an hour long episode of Pensado's Place on YouTube the other night and thought wow, THIS is my TV now. Screw the big stations!
2014/10/16 15:39:02
FastBikerBoy
Yep, there's plenty of good programs on BBC 4. In fact I probably watch that more than I do BBC1 & 2. Perhaps they should move the drivel to BBC 4 instead and move the decent stuff back to one & two.
2014/10/16 15:51:08
Kalle Rantaaho
According to an international analysis made quite a few years (25??) ago more TV-channels never means significantly wider sortiment of programs.
In the tighter competition situation all channels start to copy the moves that are succesfull on the competing channels. The main operators in big countries can afford one or two channels for more serious/ambitious material, but vast majority of broadcasting time is filled with similar material.
I very much agree with Sir David, not only concerning BBC, but TV in the world in general. There's some excellent and ambitious stuff here and there, of course, but the amount of what I call junk is so overwhelming.
 
Today, when big international networks rule in most (european) countries the situation in many smaller countries is grimm. Domestic drama/theater, documentaries and educational material are wiped out. The only options are joint ventures which are usually made with anglo-american point of view. Qualitywise they can be good, though, of course.
Visiting France last week we (I and my journalist-better-half) were yellow and green of jealousy and envy seeing how much time and professional skill they can invest in, say, political or cultural debate programs there, in prime time. 
AFAIK in Europe the main channels are more or less state owned in all countries, so they have a duty not to just run after viewer ratings, but also offer material that could not be produced with only financial profit in mind.
I think it's good, just like hospitals and schools have duties beyond profit. But they are slipping from that rule, at least in Finland, due to the poor economy.
 
I don't watch any form of reality-TV or cooking programs, nor shows with a continuing story, so there's not much on TV for me in Finland :o/ :o) My biggest TV-delighhts are some classic comedy-shows like Third Stone From The Sun, King of Brooklyn and the likes and few newer ones as well (the english names of which I don't remember).
And of course the gigantic nature documentaries by BBC and the likes.
2014/10/16 16:42:20
bitflipper
The BBC and BBC America provide a hefty portion of what I watch on television. Maybe only the good stuff makes it to America. Although "Dr. Who" does call that hypothesis into question.
 
 
2014/10/16 16:59:21
UbiquitousBubba
I enjoyed Happy Valley (mentioned earlier) and Broadchurch earlier this year. They (as with many BBC creations) were well written and brilliantly performed.
 
(I don't watch cooking or game shows, either. I do enjoy other brainless fare on occasion. You probably couldn't tell.)
2014/10/16 17:49:00
Zonno
bitflipper
.......maybe only the good stuff makes it to America...... 



http://forum.cakewalk.com/Profile/507/
 
 
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account