• Songs
  • Like A Rolling Stoned Rock - Written By Dymon Garfunklan, arr. Bapu (p.3)
2012/06/21 14:45:49
bapu
jamesg1213


Yes, I gottit Ed, I ain't stoopid. The track as a whole started on one level and stayed that way, that's what I meant by dynamics - the arrangement really. Leaving some instruments out then adding them in later would have helped that I think. Nothing wrong with the vocals, you do 1000 times better than I ever would.

I gnu ewe ent stoopid.


I may go back and remix the instruments. I agree that it it pretty much stays the same. The only (slight) progressive changes I made was the bass track. The first verse and chorus was mostly root notes. Then, from 2nd verse on I did a bit more runs (especially on the verses). Then on the outro I played an entirely different set of runs for the three chords (than I did during the song).


I was contemplating doing what you said, but again the goal was to have it posted by midnight (my time) last night. And.... I missed that by 20 minutes. I don't have NagBap installed.


Thanks for the input James.
2012/06/21 15:14:24
Wookiee
Nice ED so the mix and arrangement need a little work it was good.


2012/06/21 16:51:21
Mooch4056
That's 6 minutes and 2 seconds of my life I'll never get back again .

What's up with the vocal? 

Even bob Dylan is complaining about how bad your voice is. 

I think I'd rather be bullied as a bus monitor by grade school kids on the last day of school in new York rather than here bapu sing anymore

Just kidding 


It was really good 



Just kidding 


Or AM I ?
2012/06/21 16:54:31
bapu
Wookiee


Nice ED so the mix and arrangement need a little work it was good.



Thanks for stopping by Wookiee.

I have some ideas for the arrangement. The mix was finalized with the Rock Exciter preset. No real effort as my goal was to post by midnight come h3ll or high water. 

I'll probably revisit the song this weekend (burned out from hearing for over 8 hours straight last night).
2012/06/21 16:57:15
bapu
Mooch4056


That's 6 minutes and 2 seconds of my life I'll never get back again .

What's up with the vocal? 

Even bob Dylan is complaining about how bad your voice is. 

I think I'd rather be bullied as a bus monitor by grade school kids on the last day of school in new York rather than here bapu sing anymore

Just kidding 


It was really good 



Just kidding 


Or AM I ?

Hey Mooch. Thanks for the honest remarks (not sure which one was, but thanks) and wasting taking the listening time.


Bob Dylan And Paul Simon approved my version. Well, HFA allowed me to use the songs for $15 a pop but you get my drift, roight?
2012/06/21 16:58:19
bapu
BTW Mooch. If you want I can do my Karaoke Trance Celtic version at the wedding.

All you have to do is ask.
2012/06/21 17:01:48
Mooch4056


I'll probably revisit the song this weekend (burned out from hearing for over 8 hours straight last night).

Holy crap! You listened to that for EIGHT hours .... I would have shot myself after the first 30 minutes 




Well .... Good job on being able to withstand bad vocals for so long ...I'm impressed 


+1


Go Bapu!!




I thought doing the Chicago marathon in 7 hours was brutal ..... You got me beat...hats off to you!!!   WOW!
2012/06/21 17:05:02
bapu
Mooch4056

Well .... Good job on being able to withstand bad vocals for so long ...I'm impressed 
Go Bapu!! 

See how I'm able to put up with you for a whole weekend?


Thank heavens on the next trip you'll be heavily occupied and I can enjoy your friends and family. Mostly I want to ask what they had to endure as training to be able to hang with you for so many years. Should be some good stories and maybe I'll get a pointer or two for further down the road.
 
2012/06/21 17:10:38
Mooch4056
bapu


Mooch4056

Well .... Good job on being able to withstand bad vocals for so long ...I'm impressed 
Go Bapu!! 

See how I'm able to put up with you for a whole weekend?


Thank heavens on the next trip you'll be heavily occupied and I can enjoy your friends and family. Mostly I want to ask what they had to endure as training to be able to hang with you for so many years. Should be some good stories and maybe I'll get a pointer or two for further down the road.

Why are you being so mean and sarcastic?  Its just a song ... I'm not mad just cuz u cant sing. God made everyone different. With your vocal he made it bad ..it's ok though 

2012/06/21 19:10:16
SteveStrummerUK
 
 
              
 
 
 
 
 
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account