When you described this, it sounded like it shouldn't work, but somehow it did.  It actually came out pretty good too.  Very nice mix and production work too. 

My hat's off to you for setting a plan and knocking ot out the way you did.  Good job, Ed.

You sang it better than Dylan ;-) Classic tune Seems to have a lot of energy in the mid band. And the guitar(s) seem maybe a little too HPF'ed?

You did your own version nicely. I would not have been able to resist on parts like "TO CONCEAL!!??" I don't get the sounds of silence mix, but it seemed to work.

you beat me to it. I've wanted to do this song for a long time. 
Guess I'll have to settle for 'where have all the flowers gone'
Nice Job Baps...

The Band19



 I don't get the sounds of silence mix, but it seemed to work.

Since it was "I Am A Rock" and not "Sounds of Silence" I think it works.



Like A Rolling Stone
I Am A Rock
Everybody must get stoned*




*Yes, I sang "Everyone", my bad. And I know it's not the title but I wanted to show the relationship.



Thanks for listening Robby.

Cool project! It's a treat to hear someone actually singing this song.  Isn't it a shame that Dylan couldn't sing?

So I didn't know that mr Bloomfield started out in the music business as a janitor? Well you learned something new every day here. All my (59) year old brain remembers was there's a story behind the organ part being compromised but Mr Bob liked it and it stayed, that's my story and I'm sticking to it. Don't listen to Mooch, he doesn't understand how hard it is to sing and play bass at the same time.

Fun stuff . I find the vocals sit too far back. Bring em up and let em shine. The performance sounded pretty good to me overall. A bit lacking in bottom end here.

Cheers
Shad

Sorry I'm late to the party, or stoning, can't tell which way it's going at a couple points there on page 1. LOL! :)

This is great! I love the mixing up of lyrics on this. Thanks for taking the time to do this just on my suggestion. I can't believe it!

I really meant it when I said I thought you had a good quality to your voice and the way you did this is perfect.

I don't hear anything I'd change. Mix, vocals, instrumentation are all great.

Thanks!

Bub

bapu

... I sang "Everyone", my bad.

I did that on the very first line of In Dreams. It was one of those deals where I sang it 100 times and it turned out the first take was the best, the one with the wrong words sung.

@Herb - Thanks for listening.