How freaking ridiculous is that! I bought a video cable which turned out to be duff, so I took it back with the receipt and all the packaging. I had paid cash for it. The woman at customer service says "Ok I'm just gonna need to see your ID."
Now that annoyed me. I had ID on me of course, but out of principle I told her I didn't but that I would like a refund for the faulty goods they sold me. I asked her: what's the difference? I paid cash for it, I have the item, I have the receipt, you sold me a stinker. Why do you need to see my ID?
She told me that it was so that they could keep track of "who" is returning "what." Huh? Never heard anything so stupid in my life. She also said that since the computer system needed some record of the ID to proceed, there was no way she could bypass it. So I handled this the best way I know how: by making a scene
As if by magic, the manager appeared and promptly reassured me that he could bypass the ID requirement and return my doubloons. It really is amazing how flexible these impenetrable corporate computer systems are in the right circumstances. But jeez...Best Buy stinks.