Wood67
Nice work Steve. I've tried a few of these tools, but tend to either use a graduated ND filter, a fill-in flash for foreground and/or blend the layers by hand if bracketing. Do you find the auto tools significantly better/quicker? Where you have a reasonably clear transition point between sky/ground a pre or post filter can work pretty well provided the original exposure is a tad underexposed.
Hi Chris
I've often used Cokin ND grads before, but my concern is that using them makes it very difficult to achieve a 'natural' look. Sometimes I reckon you're better off not trying to create a balanced scene, but go all out and use the darkening the sky as an effect for its own sake.
Plus if you just want to lower the exposure on the sky, this can be done quickly and with much greater control using software. The graduated filter in Lightroom is really good, and as it's all in the software, you can assign whatever the filter does to variables other than exposure.
But although the results are pretty good, especially if you use the Lightroom grad on the first generation RAW to digital negative (DNG) file, I much prefer using HDR to create a level exposure across the image. And taking advantage of the wider exposure latitude of Camera RAW files means you can actually use a
single photograph to create an HDR image instead of multiple exposures.
By way of a quick example, here's an original RAW (Canon .CR2 file) capture rendered to .jpeg in Lightroom. As I exposed this image for the sky, the foreground is pretty much a silhouette:
Here I processed the image in Lightroom by adding a graduated (exposure) filter to the top bringing the exposure down by around 2½ stops, and then another grad to the bottom adding in an extra 2 stops to bring out the detail:
Using the original (single) RAW image with Photomatix is pretty simple, and works well in Lightroom. I just made two copies of the file and then adjusted the
overall exposure of each to mimic the effect of shooting three bracketed shots - I left one as shot, added 2 stops to one and darkened the other by around 2 stops.
I then processed the three clones in Photomatix and did a quick fiddle around in Nik Effects:
All in all, a much more satisfactory result I'd venture.